Analysis You Decide Business Law Coleman Works for Software Inc

In: Business and Management

Submitted By carincary
Words 1081
Pages 5
Factual Summary:
In this scenario, Coleman works for Software Inc. in which some of his duties included traveling to prospective clients and meeting with representatives of his sales division. During one of his sales trips he went to the mall to buy a ring for his wife that he couldn’t afford and proceeded to steal it from the jewelry store. After stealing the ring he met with John at Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar which was not a client of Coleman’s. Coleman decided to show John a cool trick that at the end it killed Jimmy and the bar sustained a lot of damage. Because of what occurred at the Bar Software Inc. terminated Coleman’s employment. Coleman decided after a week of his job being terminated that he would make amends with John. He took John out to dinner and got into an argument and punched John in the eye.
Legal Issue(s) Presented:
The issues that were presented in this scenario were:
(1) Because of what occurred at the Bar, Jimmy’s mother, John, and the 5 owners of Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar sued Software Inc. for the damaged caused by Coleman.
(2) Coleman sued Software Inc. for wrongful termination
(3) The jewelry store sued Software Inc. for the value of the ring that was stolen by Coleman.
There were several legal issues to discuss based on the different types of suits that they were bringing against Software Inc. One legal issue was when an employer is liable for the actions of an employee. Another legal issue is when an employer is able to terminate an employee.
Legal Concepts:
There are several legal concepts to discuss based on the scenario. The first legal concept is to identify the principal and the agent, and discuss their relationship. As it states in the textbook “A principal is a party who employs another person to act on his or her behalf.”1 Also, “An agent is a party who agrees to act on behalf of another.”2 The principal in this…...

Similar Documents

Mgnt 597 You Decide

...You Decide Assignment Management 597: Business Law Factual Summary Coleman is an employee for Software Inc., which requires him to spend most of his time traveling to meet customers, with the objective to sell security equipment to businesses and bars. While on a sales trip in Smalltown, Colorado, in March 2008, Coleman decided to steal a ring for his wife for an anniversary gift. Afterwards, Coleman met John, his client, at Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar. While in Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar, Coleman attempted to do a trick that consisted of lighting pre grain alcohol on fire. As a result, the bar sustained major damage and a fireball went through the room and killed Jimmy. Software Inc. terminated Coleman without interviewing him, which was a requirement for the company. After being fired, Coleman continued to act as an agent for Software Inc., and met with John again to apologize and treat him to a dinner that he stated would be paid for by Software Inc. During the dinner, John and Coleman got into an argument that led to Coleman punching John in the eye, causing severe eye damage. Issues Is Software Inc. liable for the value of the ring stolen by Coleman? Will Software Inc. be liable to Jimmy’s mom and the owners of Jimmy’s bar? Is Coleman a victim of a wrongful termination? Is Software Inc. responsible for the restaurant tab for John and Coleman’s meal? Is Software Inc. liable for the injuries sustained by John? Legal Concepts The doctrine of respondeat......

Words: 952 - Pages: 4

Mgmt 597 You Decide Week 5

...Week 5 - You Decide Factual Summary Coleman is an employee for Software INC, which requires him to spend the majority of his time traveling to meet customers with the objective to sell security equipment to businesses and bars. While on a sales trip in March of 2008 in Smalltown, Colorado, Coleman decided to steal a ring for his wife as an anniversary gift. Afterwards, Coleman met John, his client, at Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar. While in Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar. While in Jimmy’s, Coleman attempted to do a trick that consisted of lighting pre-grain alcohol on fire. As a result, the bar sustained major damage and a fireball went through the room and killed Jimmy. Software, INC terminated Cole without his account of what happened, which was a requirement for the company. After being terminated, Coleman continued to act as an agent for the company and met with John again to apologize and take him out for dinner that was paid for by Software INC. During the dinner, John and Coleman got into an argument that led Coleman to punch John in the eye, causing severe eye damage. Issues Is Software INC liable for the full value of the ring that Coleman stole while he was in Smalltown, Colorado? Will Software INC be liable to Jimmy’s mom and the owners of Jimmy’s bar? Is Coleman a victim of a wrongful termination? Is Software INC responsible for the restaurant tab for the dinner that John and Coleman had? Is Software INC liable for the injuries John sustained by......

Words: 989 - Pages: 4

You Decide Smackey Dog Food Inc.

...SMACKEY DOG FOODS, INC. Smackey Dog Foods, Inc., is a privately owned dog food manufacturing company, which was started by three sisters, Sarah, Kim, and Jillian, in the kitchen of their suburban Chicago home. They started by manufacturing a natural dog food with ingredients they bought from a local grocery store. These products were discovered by local pet stores and small grocery stores which also became distributors of their products. A larger facility was then needed as the demand steadily increased for their products. With this expansion the sisters were required to hire more workers and manage a growing company. Compared to their competitors’, Smackey Dog Foods, Inc. sales were on an upward growth trend. With increasing sales from the prior year, the sisters opened a boutique division and called it Best Boy Gourmet. Sarah, the president and general manager, has met with a banker to request a loan for $150,000 to expand the facilities and equipment. Their first loan for $150,000 was used to purchase industrial size food production equipment, which was also used as security for the loan. With this new request for a loan from the bank, they are now requiring an audit of the corporate financial statements of Smackey Dog Foods, Inc. before they will approve the new loan. My firm, Keller CPAs, has been hired to conduct an audit of Smackey’s financial statements and form an opinion about their financial statements, which will be used by the bank to help secure the...

Words: 1936 - Pages: 8

Business Law - You Decide

...Business Law - You Decide Case Resolved Question: Coleman works for Software Inc., a Delaware based corporation that sells security equipment to business and bars. Coleman’s duties include traveling to prospective clients and meeting with representatives of the businesses in his sales division. Coleman is on the road more than half the year. He often does not come home for more than a few days at a time. Over the course of his 17 years of employment with Software Inc., Coleman has had several stretches on the road that last three months or more. During a sales trip to Small-town, Colorado in March 2008, Coleman found it necessary to wash his laundry. He also wanted to buy an anniversary present for his wife. Coleman went to the mall to buy the present. While at the mall, Coleman saw a ring that he really liked but could not afford. He decided to steal it. He then went to Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar to meet with a client, John. Jimmy’s wasn’t a client of Coleman’s, but John didn’t like his customers to see him “doing business.” Coleman was talking with Jimmy about business when he spilled his drink all over the bar. That made him think about this cool trick where you put pure grain alcohol in your mouth, blow it out and light it. Coleman took a big drink, took out his lighter, and said, “What this!” He lit his lighter, blew the liquid and a fireball went through the room. The fireball hit Jimmy and killed him instantly. The bar also sustained a lot of damage.......

Words: 681 - Pages: 3

Mgmt597- You Decide

...Factual Summary Coleman works for Software, Inc. Software, Inc. sells security equipment to businesses and bars, which requires Coleman to be traveling a lot to meet with clients and representatives within his sales division. During his trip to Colorado, Coleman stole a ring from a jewelry store because he couldn’t afford it and wanted to give his wife it as an anniversary gift. Coleman also met a client named John at Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar. During this meeting Coleman spilled his drink and then decided to perform a trick where you light up the alcohol. With that being said, he took a drink, lit his lighter, and blew the liquid, which in turn created a fireball that went through the room. The fireball ended up hitting and killing Jimmy instantly and also caused major damage to the bar. Software, Inc fired Coleman immediately without interviewing him as per their policy. After Coleman was fired, he continued to act as an agent for the company and called John to express his apologies on behalf of himself and Software, Inc. He said he would take John out to dinner and Software, Inc. would pay the bill. During dinner, Coleman and John got into an argument and Coleman punched John in the eye, which caused John severe eye damage. As a result to Coleman’s actions, Jimmy’s mother (his only heir), John and Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar sued Software, Inc. for the damages caused by Coleman. Coleman sued Software, Inc. for wrongful termination because he was not interviewed prior to being......

Words: 1504 - Pages: 7

Laws 310 You Decide

...LAWS 310 - WEEK 7 ASSIGNMENT: YOU DECIDE Widget Tech Inc. Code of Ethics Professor: Sheila Hostetler LAWS 310 Devry University Review of Widget Tech Inc. Code of Ethics Table of Contents LAWS 310 - WEEK 7: YOU DECIDE Summary…………………………………………………………………..………..3 Introduction……………………….…………………………………….………..…3 How to Create a Code of Ethics………………………………………….....…....…4 Components of a Code of Ethics…………………………………… .……………4 Conclusion…………………………………………………..…………………….....6 Sources…………………………………………………...…….…………………….7 Summary Widget Tech Inc. is in need of update the company’s current code of ethics due to growth of the company and the changing workforce. Research has been conducted to revise the current LAWS 310 - WEEK 7: YOU DECIDE policy and address topics that were previously overlooked. Widget Tech Inc. is a company that stresses both corporate and personal integrity. We not only comply with laws and applicable regulations; but we also strive to conduct our affairs according to the highest ethical standards. Employees are expected to be honest and forthright in dealings with managers, subordinates and with one another, as well as with clients, suppliers, government agencies and their employees, business partners and the general public. Widget Tech employees must maintain the highest level of personal integrity and encourage it in others; they must not lie, cheat, steal or do anything that would bring dishonor upon themselves or the company...

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Software Inc

...Facts In this scenario, Coleman works for Software Inc. in which some of his duties included traveling to prospective clients and meeting with representatives of his sales division. During one of his sales trips he went to the mall to buy a ring for his wife that he couldn’t afford and proceeded to steal it from the jewelry store. After stealing the ring he met with John at Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar which was not a client of Coleman’s. Coleman decided to show John a cool trick that at the end it killed Jimmy and the bar sustained a lot of damage. Because of what occurred at the Bar Software Inc. terminated Coleman’s employment. Coleman decided after a week of his job being terminated that he would make amends with John. He took John out to dinner and got into an argument and punched John in the eye. Issues The issues that were presented in this scenario were: 1. Because of what occurred at the Bar, Jimmy’s mother, John, and the 5 owners of Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar sued Software Inc. for the damaged caused by Coleman. 2. Coleman sued Software Inc. for wrongful termination 3. The jewelry store sued Software Inc. for the value of the ring that was stolen by Coleman. There were several legal issues to discuss based on the different types of suits that they were bringing against Software Inc. One legal issue was when an employer is liable for the actions of an employee. Another legal issue is when an employer is able to terminate an employee. Legal......

Words: 670 - Pages: 3

Devry Laws 310 You Decide

...Business Entities: Memo to Gloria Smithson LAWS 310 Professor TO: Gloria Smithson, Business Owner FROM: DATE: May 24, 2015 SUBJECT: Business Entities In today’s world, putting up one’s own business is better than becoming an employee considering that people can come up with various business ventures and ideas. However, not everyone who puts up their own business succeed primarily because of failure in identifying the correct business structure for their endeavor. To get the most out of a small business venture, it is crucial to choose the perfect structure that fits the type of business in order to maximize the potentials of the business, including maximizing financial and operational success. Therefore, identifying the appropriate business entity is necessary to guarantee the success of a business venture. Rules may vary depending on country, state, or province. The Scenario The husband and wife team of Joe and Gloria Smithson have come up with a new and more efficient widget that could help transform the energy industry from what it is today. Finding the confidence that they have already perfected the design, the husband and wife team created a prototype and designated a lawyer to file for design and utility patent applications. The next step therefore is registering the company and identifying the business entity type that would insulate her and her family from personal liability for debts of the business, or liability in the event of injury caused by......

Words: 1451 - Pages: 6

Analysis of Right to Work Laws

...greatest strengths has been its economic structure and diversity. As citizens and business professionals, we owe a lot of this to the Constitutional system of government. With a balance of power between the states and the Federal government, this country is ripe for economic development. Wall Street is one of our country’s icons, and affluent business tycoons such as Donald Trump, J. Willard Marriott, Sam Walton, and Warren Buffett receive celebrity status. This economic strength has carried us through war and peace. In fact, images of Rosie the Riveter represent how we secured the home front during World War (National Park Service). More recently, it was economic strategy (and this country’s outright economic dominance) that led to the fall of Communism and the end of the Cold War. (Garrity, 2002). Individual prosperity is a fundamental principle of our economic system, and is as important as collective wealth. One need not belong to an elite class or family (although it does help if you are related to millionaires), nor does one have to obtain special permission from the government. Another element of the economic system is the way it rewards success. If you seek it, you can find it; all you need is to find a way to build a better widget, or a better way to build what everyone else has been making. At least in theory, the system is designed in such a way as to reward ingenuity, work ethic, and perseverance. Unfortunately, not everything about this capitalist......

Words: 5681 - Pages: 23

You Decide Work

...Jaromny Mercedes Business Economics Professor: Faisal Ruben Harahap (PP2) Chapter 15 Question 14 What are some of the limitations of the national income accounts in how they represent our standard of living? The problem is that that looking at national income accounts only give us an idea of the quantitative arena of the standard of living of a given region and not the qualitative arena of their life. For example, those income accounts will give us an idea of the amount of money that each family has on average and per capita.  However, they do not give an idea of the areas that deal with the quality of life.  What are the schools like (education)?  What is the life expectancy for that location? There may be two countries that have similar income levels on average but one country has a much higher level of education and life expectancy for their country as opposed to the other one.  Even though they have similar income levels and GNP measures, you could argue that one country still has a far better standard of living due to the non-monetary aspects (education and life expectancy). Chapter 16 Question 6  Explain why hyperinflation has such a devastating impact on economies. Explain what it takes to stop hyperinflation. Hyperinflation has a devastating effect on economies for two reasons. Firstly, one function of money is a store of value. Hyperinflation destroys this stored value making people less well off. If people lose all stored value, they are unable to...

Words: 371 - Pages: 2

Business Analysis of Apple, Inc

...Business Analysis of Apple, Inc. Padma L. Dongre MGT521 Nov 28, 2011 Dr. Stephen McCann Background. Apple Inc. designs, manufactures, and markets personal computers, portable digital music players, and mobile communication devices. It sells a variety of related software, services, peripherals, and networking solutions. The Company sells its products worldwide through its online stores, retail stores, direct sales force, and third-party wholesalers, and resellers. In addition, the Company sells a variety of third-party Macintosh ("Mac"), iPod, iPhone, iPad compatible products, including application software, printers, storage devices, speakers, headphones, and various other accessories and peripherals through its online and retail stores. The Company sells to education, consumer, creative professional, business, and government customers. The Company's fiscal year is the 52 or 53-week period that ends on the last Saturday of September. The Company's strategy also includes expanding its distribution network to effectively reach more of its targeted customers and provide them with a high-quality sales and post-sales support experience. Financial Analysis: Detailed financial statements are available in Appendix A. This information provides immense detail in the financial status of Apple, Inc. over time. Combined with data regarding product sales, much can be derived to analyze Apple’s strength. Revenue rose 40% in......

Words: 1022 - Pages: 5

Gm597: You Decide

...Coleman works for Software Inc., a Delaware based corporation that sells security equipment to businesses and bars. Coleman travels to prospective clients and meetings with representatives of the businesses in his sales division. Coleman conducted a sales trip to Smalltown, Colorado in March 2008. Coleman saw a ring that he really liked but could not afford it, so he stole the ring. He later went to Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar to meet with a client. Coleman was talking with Jimmy about business when he spilled his drink all over the bar. Colman poured alcohol in his mouth, blew it and it flew across the room and killed Jimmy instantly. The bar sustained a lot of damage. Sofware Inc. fired Coleman with justifying his case. Software Inc.’s handbook required all employees to be interviewed before termination. A week later, Coleman called John to make amends and they instantly got into an argument because John told Coleman he was fat. Coleman punched John in the eye, causing severe eye damage. Jimmy’s mother, John, and Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar sued Software Inc. for the damage caused by Coleman. Coleman sues Software Inc. for wrongful termination and the jewelry store sued Software Inc. for the value of the ring. Negligence Under the common law, negligence requires that a defendant has a duty to avoid the foreseeable risk of injury to a plaintiff, defendant breaches that duty, defendant is the actual and legally proximate cause of plaintiff’s injuries, and plaintiff suffers......

Words: 842 - Pages: 4

You Decide/Employment Law

...Employment Law HR593 You Decide Assignment   You Decide Assignment Scenario Summary: Karen is a human resources consultant at a local utility. Originally, the work requested was project-based. Karen was asked to develop training materials for an upcoming session on diversity. Cynthia, the human resources manager, was very happy with the work that Karen did and asked her to work on some additional projects. Before everyone knew it, Karen had been working at the utility for five years. Karen has been paid a monthly base salary of $10,000 per month. Karen has received a 1099 for her wages over the past five years, but has not received a W-2. Karen was not offered any benefits, but when she was hired, she did not need them, as she was happily married. However, Karen's husband recently passed away and she asked Cynthia about receiving benefits. Cynthia has denied Karen's request. Karen's title, when she started, was Human Resources Temporary, but her new title evolved into Human Resources Consultant to be more consistent with others in the department who are doing work similar to hers. Karen does have a contract with the utility. Karen has had other limited clients over the years. She had one client for an approximately 40-hour project two years ago, and she currently has another client that keeps her on a retainer basis. Since she was denied benefits, Karen has contacted the IRS to ask them to determine her status. Your role/Assignment: Your role is to......

Words: 1293 - Pages: 6

Business Law You Decide

...Sarah Glaudel You Decide Assignment Business Law Factual Summary: In this case, Coleman works for Software Inc., in which his duties include traveling to prospective clients and meeting with representatives of the businesses in his particular sales division. During a trip to Colorado in March 2008, Coleman stole a ring that he could not afford as an anniversary gift to his wife. After the theft, Coleman met with his client John at Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar where, through a series of events, Coleman killed Jimmy with an alcohol fireball and caused sustainable damage to the bar. Because of these actions, Software Inc. fired Coleman without the required interview as stated in the employee handbook. A week later, Coleman took John out to dinner to make amends where he proceeded to punch John in the eye, causing severe physical damage. Issue(s): Because of the actions carried out by Coleman, Jimmy’s mother, John, and Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar sued Software Inc. for the damage caused by Coleman. In addition, Coleman sued Software Inc. for wrongful termination and the jewelry store sued Software Inc. for the value of the ring that was stolen by Coleman. In order to determine which of these suits are lawful, we need to discuss the following legal concepts: when is an employer liable for the actions of an employee and when/how is an employer able to terminate an employee? Legal Concepts: To begin, we will discuss the legal concepts surrounding an employer-employee......

Words: 1219 - Pages: 5

Essay-You Decide Mgmt 597

...Nanette Toledo You Decide- Week 5 MGMT -597 The facts of this case are presented below. Coleman, an employee of Software Inc., worked mostly on the road servicing and visiting customers around the country. In one of his trips, he decided to stop by a jewelry store to buy a gift for his wedding anniversary to his wife, but was too expensive. Instead, he stole a ring because he could not afford it. After that he went on a business meeting at Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar to see John, a customer. He spilled his drink and after that decided to do a flame with his mouth using grain alcohol. He killed Jimmy and did serious damage on the property. Software Inc. policy to fire employees is to have a final interview with him, but they fail to do so with Coleman, due to the severity of the happening. Even though he was fired, he arranged a meeting to do a sorry dinner for what happened at the bar with John, stating that Software Inc. would pay for everything. At the dinner, John called Coleman fat, and he responded by punching John in the eye and causing severe damage. Jimmy’s mom, John, Jimmy’s Poor-Man’s Bar (partnership owned by 5 partners), and the jewelry store sued Software Inc. for the damages caused by their employee. There are some questions or problems arising from this situation. First of all, Software Inc. needed to give Coleman the final interview upon as establish on Software Inc. employee’s contract. Can Coleman win this termination sue? Also if the incidents......

Words: 990 - Pages: 4