Barriers to Using Evidence Based Medicin

In: Business and Management

Submitted By mossman
Words 3924
Pages 16
Barriers to Using Evidence-Based Medicine
Melanie Ossman
Granite State College
Professor Philip Wyzik
HLTC 600
March 4, 2011

Thesis
The Institute of Medicine recommends the use of evidence-based medicine as a primary tool for achieving the aims outlined by their six themes of improvement. Specifically, EBM relates to their aim to make health care more effective: “to provide health care that is effective and efficient.” (Institute of Medicine, 2001) In recent years, evidence-based medicine has gained increasingly broad-based support in health care, but many doctors still aren’t using it. With a lean towards Pharmacy management, I researched the barriers providers and institutions are faced with in successfully incorporating evidence-based medicine and how initiating organizational improvements can help. The research highlights some important considerations to be aware of that gives evidence-based medicine a bad name, the pitfalls to avoid, and some ways providers and institutions are working to overcome them.

Introduction
This paper begins by giving an overview of evidence-based medicine, what it is, and the benefits to be realized by providers, insurers, and patients. I compared that to what providers were using before EBM. Next, I examine the barriers to successfully incorporating evidence-based medicine, and the negative perceptions that dissuade their use by clinicians. Identified are the disadvantages such as source information bias, ethics considerations, and the dangers in using EBM to set Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPG).
The research highlights some important considerations to be aware of that gives evidence-based medicine a bad name. I looked at pitfalls to avoid and some ways providers and institutions are working to overcome them. Finally, I included an overview, from a pharmacy management perspective, of how improvements techniques…...

Similar Documents

Evidence- Based

...Evidence-Based Nursing Practice Many professional associations, federal government agencies, and other organizations, using research findings and other evidence have developed clinical practice guidelines and standards of care through the years to improve the healthcare practices. The reasons why different groups have come together and have established and implemented guidelines and standards are because there have been many problems and issues that the healthcare setting have encountered. Theses guidelines reduce or decrease, “Never Events”, while improving quality care and patient safety. The purpose of this paper is to review the guidelines that has been developed to address the Urinary Tract Infections (UTI) problem, it’s importance and significance to nursing practice, as well as its impact on the patients and community, and the differences in care based on evidence. “Patients with indwelling catheters, even with current standards of care and evidence-based practice, urinary tract infections continue to be a problem”(Kevin J. Ribby, June 2006). Practice setting problem Urinary tract infections continue to be a problem in healthcare. The numbers of patient’s with urinary tract infections are still too high. “A plethora of articles have been written about nosocomial urinary catheter-related infections, management of the catheter, and proper placement of the indwelling catheter in the male patient 4 but little about the impact of nursing education on outcomes related......

Words: 1222 - Pages: 5

Evidence Based Practice

...agent for surgical insertion of a CVC or is there an alternative proven through evidence- based practice to be a more effective anti-microbial. A2a. Basis for Practice Procedures and protocols are researched by the safety committee who release their findings to the clinical practice committee for review and evaluation. In a culture that use to accept betadine as the primary anti-microbial agent to cleanse the skin prior to CVC insertion has been questioned and through evidence based practice is in favor of using chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) as the primary agent by identifying and concluding that it is superior to betadine by reducing the risk of SSIs by approximately 50% (Chaiyakunapruk, Veenstra, Saint, and Lipsky (2009). If the clinical practice committee approves the use of CHG for CVC insertion it is communicated to the department of nursing followed by the nurse managers, educators and staff nurses. A2b. Rationale CHG and betadine are anti-microbial agents that reduce the incidence of primary SSIs. Cleansing the surgical incision site of the CVC is practiced by disinfecting the skin which aids in the destruction of microbes by reducing the incidences of SSIs. A2c. Explanation Jones (2006) described catheter-related infections as significant, which increases the morbidity and mortality of critically ill patients as well as an increase in hospital costs. Because evidence based practice, the results indicated that CHG was a superior anti-microbial......

Words: 1475 - Pages: 6

Evidence Based Practice

...discipline, which is dependant upon a high level of professionalism,ethics and human values that demand for intellect, skills and a high sense of social responsibility.The knowledge and essential skill that increased dramatically make nurses leading and developing new services in health care delivery. Nurses roles and resposibilities will continue to change in line with the health reforms that are improving care for patients.Therefore, nurses need to be encouraged to integrate the best available evidence with clinical judgment and the current climate in health care requires nuses to be able to apply the best evidence, usually through using research in order to provide the most effective health care. EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE Evidence- based practice(EBP) is currently seen as being central to the delivery of quality healthcare. EBP has been defined as an approach to problem solving in clinical practice which involves asking questions and searching literature in order to adopt an evidence-based intervention for a problem (Rosenberg & Donald,1995 ) . Nurses are also expected to contribute to the development of EBP. The changes in the health service make this a time of opportunity for the nursing profession. The starting point for any strategy to promote EBP in nursing is to articulate the ways in which nurses engage in research at different points in their carrier .If nurses can actively engage with EBP, they can make a major contribution towards improving patient......

Words: 4203 - Pages: 17

Evidence Based Practice

...decision making within nursing practice. Cullum et al (2007) identifies four requirements:-Clinical experience, valid researched evidence, available resources and lastly but no less important the patient preferences and experiences. The area of clinical practice to be studied is within a community district nursing team consisting of 7 qualified nurses and 3 health care assistants. The location is situated within a seaside town with a large population of over 65 year olds. Through clinical experience, the author has found a flaw in quality of care when nursing staff are using the overview assessment document which has been adapted from the single assessment process produced by the Department of Health (DOH, 2002). When assessing nutrition there is a series of six questions and an asterisk to consider the “Malnutrition Universal Screening Tool” (MUST, 2003) however experience in practice would suggest the tool (MUST, 2003) isn't used and a local unknown screening tool is used on some rare occasions. The author feels management of these vulnerable patients is lacking and in order to improve patient care a clarification of guidance and service change maybe required. Exploring Cullum's (2007) theory of decision making, the author needs to justify the service change with valid researched evidence. As a nurse in practice it can be argued that evidence based practice isn’t routinely reviewed as part of our practice and guidance is given from colleagues and Pravikoff et al......

Words: 4463 - Pages: 18

Evidence Based Practice

...Examine the ways that health professionals can use the five steps of evidence-based practice (EBP) as a practical framework to overcoming barriers to locating, appraising and applying best research evidence. Use an occupational health and safety practice as an example. Examples of occupational health and safety practices include: *  Use of professional protective equipment (e.g. gloves) *  Safety considerations when using equipment (e.g. sharps) *  (or a topic you select yourself in negotiation with your LIC) Health professionals are very good at seeking information from their clients and their families and also from the settings in which they work but however they have not been as aware of the information that they can gain from research. Although they need information from many sources, evidence based practice shows how research can also play a role in informing clinical decisions, (Hoffmann ,2010). Health professionals use the five steps of evidence-based practice (EBP) as a structure to overcoming barriers and applying best research. Examples of this include use of professional protective equipment and safety considerations when using equipment. Liamputtong (2010) states that evidence based practice is a “process that requires the practitioner to find empirical evidence about the effectiveness or efficacy of different treatment options and then determine the relevance of the evidence to a particular clients situation” (pp. 252). Sackett (1996,......

Words: 1167 - Pages: 5

Evidence Based Practice

...EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE BENCY GNANASIGHAMANI AMERICAN SENTINEL UNIVERSITY Introduction Medical and health care is one of the most dynamic human disciplines, and large amounts of money are spent annually on high-quality and sophisticated research, resulting in an exponential growth in health care literature. Regularly, new and more effective medicines, medical devices, and procedures are invented. One major objective behind all these efforts is to help doctors, nurses, and medical technicians provide the best possible care and treatment to patients. In addition to using traditional and well-established procedures and practices, health care practitioners are adopting innovative interventions that are based on best practices as well as solid research-based evidence. Evidence-based practice is one such technique and is quickly gaining popularity due to its potential to effectively handle clinical issues and provide better patient care (ANA 2003). Implementation of Evidence Based Practice places additional demands on nurses to apply credible evidence to individual client situations through searching related evidence, using clinical judgments, and considering client values and system resources. To effectively apply the Evidence Based Practice process, in addition to the basic skills required to undertake nursing work, a nurse must have the ability to: identify knowledge gaps, formulate relevant questions, conduct an......

Words: 2400 - Pages: 10

Evidence-Based Marketing

...April 9, 2014 Article Review Evidence-based Marketing Article Summary The practice of using evidence as the base for making decisions has been employed successfully in many industries such as healthcare, nursing, criminal justice, ect.. Unfortunately, in the world of marketing, “there has been no explicit consideration of the applicability of the concepts of evidence-based practice or evidence-based management” yet (Rowley, p. 523). The article, then, provides information on challenges practitioners face when deciding whether to implement the evidence-based marketing theory and explores some alternative relationships between researchers and practitioners that may improve the use of the evidence-based methods. Using evidence for marketing decision-making is well recognized as a helpful, more accurate method of making better decisions. As suggested in the article, the type of such evidence in this method should be research evidence that is “reviewed and summarised in a systematic way that allows reasonably clear conclusions to be reached about what we know and do not know” and “integrated into the decision-making process in an explicit way such that its relevance and usefulness to the decision is made clear” (Rowley, p. 526). However, this method has only been tested mainly from academic researches and may lack applicability to businesses due to the gap between researchers and practitioners. Rowley cited in the article four distinct barriers practitioner faces when......

Words: 1098 - Pages: 5

Evidence Based Practise in Nursing

...Hand hygiene is a practise of evidence-based medicine and the number one way to prevent health-care associated infections (Garbutt, 2011). The term of hand hygiene applies to adequate hand washing, antiseptic hand-wash, antiseptic hand-rub, or surgical hand antisepsis (Garbutt, 2011). Evidence-based practices have been put into place to prevent such infections from occurring. The present paper will examine ways in which health professionals use the five steps of evidence based practices (EBP) to locate, appraise and apply the best available research evidence. In this case, the five steps of EBP will be assessed in conjunction to the practise of good hand hygiene. Liamputtong (2013, p.267) has explained evidence-based practise (EBP) as the use of the best research evidence, clinical expertise, available resources, and patient preferences in respect to clinical decision-making. EBP is taught and practised using five steps to reduce inconsistency and increase efficiency and effectiveness of health care (Liamputtong, 2013, p.267). According to Liamputtong (2013, p.267) the first step of EBP is to ask an answerable question stating the population, intervention, comparison and outcome of the question (PICO). Next, acquire the best available evidence using research strategies (Liamputtong, 2013, p.267). This evidence is then appraised to determine its quality and relevance (Liamputtong, 2013, p.267). The fourth step it to apply the evidence integrated with clinical expertise......

Words: 1068 - Pages: 5

Evidence Based Practice

...“The critical appraisal of the research evidence associated with an area of my professional practice” Introduction I am going to critically appraise of research evidence on treatment of urinary stress incontinence in women with obesity. I chose this topic because currently I am working in urology department in hospital X, I am always have the chance to deal with women experiencing stress incontinence. In current practice we will teach them behavioral intervention program (pelvic floor exercise and bladder training) to lower the severity of urine leakage. That is why I want to explore more on this issue and see whether the use of vaginal cones also effective in treatment with behavioral intervention program. Obesity is a common problem in developed countries, with an incidence of 33% (Roreyt 1998), this problem may directly leading to stress urinary incontinence (Ouslander 1996) which may hinder the normal daily life of an adult. In Hong Kong Hospital Authority (HA) policy, there are no guideline in related to treatment regarding stress incontinence, it is always depends on surgeon’s preferences. Therefore I want to search for research evidence in associated with treatment of urinary stress incontinence which may beneficial in my working place. Main Body The two answerable questions formulated using PICO tool are: Quantitative Question – In women with obesity, how does behavioral intervention program compared to vaginal cones influence the occurrence of......

Words: 3294 - Pages: 14

Evidence Based Practice

...person, except to the extent of collaboration and/or group work as defined in the unit outline. 4. this assignment has not been recycled, using work substantially the same as work I have completed previously and which has been counted towards satisfactory completion of another unit of study or credited towards another qualification, unless the Lecturer in Charge has granted prior written consent to do so. 5. a copy of the original assignment is retained by me and that I may be required to submit the original assignment to the Lecturer in Charge upon request. 6. the Lecturer-in-Charge may, for the purpose of assessing this assignment: 1. reproduce this assignment; 2. authorise the reproduction of this assignment; 3. provide a copy of this assignment to another member of the University; and/or 4. communicate, or authorise communication of, a copy of this assignment to a plagiarism checking service, such as the “Turnitin” service operated by iParadigms LLC (or such other service utilised by the University at its absolute discretion). I acknowledge that a plagiarism checking service provider may then retain a copy of this assignment on its database for the purpose of future plagiarism checking. Signature of student(s): ___________________________________________ Date: 30/03/2014 Question: Describe Evidence Based Practices. Nurses are constantly challenged to stay tuned with new information to provide the highest quality of patient......

Words: 1854 - Pages: 8

Evidence Based Practice

...Implementation of Evidence-Based Practice Sheila Wright Submitted to Sharon Mooney, RN, MSN in partial fulfillment of NR 460R Evidence-Based Practice in Nursing Regis University April 9, 2010 Implementation of Evidence-Based Practice Throughout history, nursing practice has experienced change. Florence Nightingale initiated the greatest change in nursing in the mid-1800’s when she gathered data regarding the morbidity and mortality of soldiers (Chitty & Black, 2007). Nightingale recognized there was a need for change to improve patient outcomes. Her determination to provide the best possible care, based on the evidence she gathered, has inspired a profession. Today, the process of using research to care for patients is referred to as evidence-based practice. The purpose of this paper is to define and explain the importance of evidence-based practice, discuss qualitative and quantitative research studies which affect medical-surgical areas, and barriers preventing research utilization and how they may be overcome. Definition of Evidence-Based Practice There are numerous definitions of evidence-based practice (EBP). EBP is defined by Boswell and Cannon (2007) as, “A research-based, decision-making process used to guide the delivery of holistic patient care by nurses” (p. 340). Cope (as cited in Chitty & Black, 2007), defines EBP as “using the best available research findings to make clinical decisions that are most effective and beneficial for......

Words: 1434 - Pages: 6

Evidence Based Practice

...Evidence Based Practice Western Governors University Tracy Wallace Hospital-acquired pneumonia has a very high morbidity and mortality rate here in the United States and is the second most common nosocomial infection. HAP consists of approximately fifteen percent of all hospital-acquired infections and occurs in five to fifteen percent of every 1,000 admissions. Critical care nurses are presented with unique challenges when caring for patients who are at risk for developing VAP. Strategies must be developed using evidence-based practice and incorporated into daily care in order to prevent VAP in patients receiving mechanical ventilation. ICU Doctors, Nurse Educators and the DON on the ICU unit are currently responsible for our current oral care practice. Our hospital is currently using (OAG), which stands for Eiders’ Oral Assessment Guide, it measures a patient’s oral health status and the frequency of oral hygiene. This tool measures oral health by using 8 different categories: swallow, lips, tongue, saliva, mucous membranes, gingiva, teeth, and voice. They are graded 1 (best), 2, or 3 (worst). Normal findings would be a score of 8, whereas 24 would be the total worst score in all 8 categories. I will now explain how using evidence based practice and OAG can improve the oral health of patients on ventilators. The conclusion will be supported by the research that I have obtained in this research project, which is decreasing the risk of pneumonia on patients who are on......

Words: 1716 - Pages: 7

Evidence Based Practice in Nursing

...Evidence Based Practices Abstract Quality nursing and outcomes have a strong correlation with evidence based practices, a model that guides patient provider decision making and health care. Evidence based practices uses contentious and judicious use of current best evidence in decision making about the care of individual patients. Strong nursing and organizational leadership is needed to invest in nurses ability and the resources to facilitate evidence based practices. With business principles applied to quality health care the return on investment can increase revenues, saving costs, increases patient safety, and achieves the highest quality care. Keywords: clinical decision making, patient safety, best health care outcomes Evidence Based Practices in Nursing Evidence based practices occurs in many disciplines but most recently it has occurred in the discipline of nursing. Evidence based practices helps to identify and recognize the best health outcomes for patients and their families obtained through clinical expertise and best scientific evidences. Health care professionals are constantly asking questions in regards to health care practices in regards to how and why practices are being performed the way they are. Health care professionals want to know if the way they are caring for a patient is the best way or is there another method that is more effective. In a dynamic health care setting these questions are being asked to ensure quality care and safety for......

Words: 1403 - Pages: 6

Change Using Evidence Based Research

...RUNNING HEAD: CHANGE USING EVIDENCE BASED RESEARCH Change Using Evidence Based Research Glenda Doctor Western Governor’s University Procedure, basis for practice, rationale and explanation The procedure for the use of povidone-iodine for surgical cite antisepsis is: skin preparation for surgery includes the use of sterile drapes to drape the patient and square off surgical area with sterile towels to absorb excess solution. The incision site is where the prep begins and proceeds outward from that point. Iodine soap or scrub, wet the skin with sterile water the iodine scrub will be added to the point of lather, the site is to be scrubbed for 5 minutes. Excess solution is to be blotted with sterile towels or sterile gauze. When iodine paint is used the iodine paint will be applied and allowed to dry before first incision. This practice of surgical skin preparation has been a standard for many years. At this facility povidone-iodine is used predominantly however a few surgeons do use chlorhexidine, it has typically been surgeon choice for skin preparation. Studies have shown that Chlorhexidine-alcohol is a superior product to povidone-iodine to reduce skin colonization and reduce surgical site infection, (Darouiche, Wall, Itani, Otterson, Webb, Carrick, & ... Berger, 2010). No specific use for either product was found in the policy and procedures for the hospital on the hospital web site. There were no available protocols involving the products......

Words: 3331 - Pages: 14

Evidence Based Practice

...healthcare workers is a must. This would obtain certification in wound care and be responsible for the ongoing continued education for wound prevention, monitoring and maintenance. The staff will be educated and trained at quarterly intervals on wound identification, staging, prevention, maintenance and monitoring. Key words: wound care, evaluation, pressure ulcers, multidisciplinary, specialist, evidence The Significance of Having a Multidisciplinary Team 4 Problem Identified The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) declared in October of 2008 that it will no longer provide reimbursement for hospital acquired pressure ulcers (HAPUs) because it is a preventable occurrence (CMS, 2014). Even though the percentages of occurrences have declined since then, HAPUs continue to cause financial strain on institutions (estimated $9.1- $11.6 billion dollars loss annually) (Leaf Healthcare Inc., 2014). Nurses are in a position to decrease these numbers but barriers remain. Staff nurses in acute care settings, as well as hospital based transitional units provide care for patients with multiple diagnoses. These nurses are required to identify potential risk factors and put in place preventative measures. Wound prevention remains one of the top priorities, but lack of knowledge and skills in wound identification, management, treatment and prevention within the units setting remains a problem. Many nurses rely on short and......

Words: 14473 - Pages: 58