Birch Case Summary

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Soda
Words 318
Pages 2
Birch Case--summary

Background: Birch Paper Company is a large and vertically integrated paper company. It has three products: white paper, Kraft paper and paperboard. The company has four producing divisions and a timberland division (supplies pulp). Each division is operated by its manager independently, and each of them is assessed based on its profit and return on investment. A decentralizing policy has been applied by top management, which has increase corporate profits and competitive position.

Situation: Thompson division designed a box for Northern division. Each box includes three parts: an inside linerboard, an outside linerboard, and the corrugating medium. Northern division paid for Thompson only the out of pocket cost of its design and development work. After that, Northern has three offers from Thompson and other two outside companies West and Erie. Usually, managers have rights to choose suppliers of materials freely, and may get sales price inside Birch. There are three bids:
1) The bid from Thompson is $480. If Thompson gets the offer, it will buy most of materials from inside Birch. These materials will cost 70% of out-of-pocket costs of $400, and is equivalent to 60% of selling price.
2) The bid from Eire Paper is $430. If Eire gets the offer, it will purchase the outside linerboard from Birch and use its own inside linerboard and corrugating medium. The outside linerboard will cost $120 a gross ($90 is the material from Southern division and $30 is for print from Thompson. And of the $30, $25 is the out of pocket cost).
3) Bid from West Paper is $432.

In the best interest of Birch Company, the manager (Kenton) of Northern should accept from Thompson because it will be the lowest cost for the company. Despite $480 seems the highest price, but actually most material are from inside of the company. Moreover, it will bring down the…...

Similar Documents

Case Summary

...commissioning on site; the balance of 10% after three months satisfactory performance.As provided in the contract, BETA paid to CONARTIST 20% of the contract price (Rs. 2,000,000) on the signing of the contract on 1 September 2010, a further 20% (Rs. 2,000,000) on 6 January 2011 upon completion of tests of the equipment at the CONARTIST works and 25% of the contract price (Rs. 2,500,000) upon delivery of the equipment to BETA site on 20 February 2011. On 29 March 2011 CONARTIST assigned to ACME the right to receive the remaining two payments, of. Since that time no payment has been made by BETA to ACME. In the case of the payment due upon commissioning on site, BETA paid it to CONARTIST on 19 April 2011, i.e., nine days after having received notice of the assignment. BETA has claimed that the notice was defective in form. These objections are manifestly unfounded. In the case of the payment due after three months satisfactory performance, BETA has refused to pay it at all. When ACME was assigned the right to payment under the contract between BETA and CONARTIST, it was necessarily assigned the right to enforce its rights in the same manner as the assignor, CONARTIST, would have had. ....

Words: 303 - Pages: 2

Birch Paper Case

...make the best business decisions for his division, which means taking the lowest legitimate and reasonable bid. By accepting the West bid, the division will save 10.4% compared to the bid of the Thompson division. If the Thompson bid were within a few dollars of the low bid, as the one from Eire Paper, it would be more reasonable to accept the bid. Also, it is at least nominally the policy of the Birch Company to accept the lowest bid, since the vice president knows the Kenton will accept the lowest bid barring any outside intervention. It is also the policy of the company to expect that inter-division bids meet the going market rate. By rejecting the Thompson division bid, Mr. Kenton shows Mr. Brunner that he will abide by both policies, and that he won’t accept unreasonably high bids. Mr. Brunner will thus be more likely to make lower bids in the future. 2. Which bid is in the best interest of Birch Paper Company? Although accepting the lowest bid would not be advantageous for the Thompson division, accepting the lowest bid is in best interest of the company. This case does not state the fixed costs that would become sunk costs if the Thompson division were to not produce the boxes, however, the division will not lose profit margin on boxes where production has not even started. Similarly, the Northern Division cannot afford to carry the cost burden of the mark up into sales. Mr. Kenton stated, “We sell in a very competitive market, where higher costs cannot be......

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

The Birch Case

...The Birch Paper Case This case was about the decision that Mr. William Kenton, the manager of the Northern division of the Birch Company had to make regarding the purchase of specialty boxes. Mr. Kenton had received three bids. The first was from the Thompson division of the Birch Company for the amount of $512 per thousand boxes, the second was from West Paper Company in the amount of $460 per thousand boxes, and the last was from Eire Paper Company in the amount of $442 per thousand boxes. Now the task for Mr. Kenton was to choose the offer that was in the best interest of the company. At first glance it would seem that the bid that should be accepted is the one made by Eire Paper Company because it was the lowest bid and had more room for profitability. Although the Eire Paper Company had the lowest bid if we evaluated the bid based on cost it would be as follows. The Thompson division would be $168($400 * 70%)* 60% added to $120($400 * 30%) to make it $288 of out of pocket cost, West Paper Company would be $460, and Eire Paper Company’s would be $401($442-$5-$36). The bid that would have been in the best interest of the Birch Company, if the divisions weren’t considered separate financial entities, is one from the Thompson Division. However, the Thompson division has its own goals in the company and accepting its bid would not be profitable for the Northern division. Since all the divisions of the Birch Company are judged on their own merits the Northern division......

Words: 367 - Pages: 2

Case Summary

...and no working experience. In May 2006, the company secured a contract worth RM 750,000. Due to shortage of funds, the company must apply banking facilities from banks. However, the banks have required the company to submit the audited financial statement for two years which sadly, the company accounts never have been audited. Due to that, the company has appointed Aziz & Co. as company auditor. Consequently, during the performance of audit, it has been found that there were many unresolved issues and the auditor want to express qualify financial statement. But Encik Zayed doesn’t want the auditor to issue qualified audit report since that would make it difficult for the company to get banking facilities. So, he hired Cik Amy. In this case, the protagonist is Cik Amy. As new finance executive, she faced few problems. The first problem is unorganized and incomplete accounting record. For example, there was missing of Accounts Receivables listing. Due to this, the second problem arose which is to entertain and fulfill the auditor needs. In addition, the director and CEO were not familiar with Accounting Standards and the provision of the Companies Act 1965. So, their lack of knowledge in those fields resulted in wrong treatment of some transactions and accounts. Incomplete information and records: Withdrawals were made from the company totaling RM12,500 without proper documentation. Besides, several pages of Account Receivables listing went missing. Listing of Account......

Words: 693 - Pages: 3

Case Summary

...The case study discusses challenges that the Iggy’s Bread of the world are experiencing ensuring effective leadership while maintain the culture of the organization. Igor and his wife Ludmilla Ivanovic both started the Pain d’Avignon bakery with no previous in baking. Passion, motivation, and dedication enabled the bakery to grow at an unprecedented rate. Upon insisting on using only organic ingredients, the Ivanovics and their partners seemed to be going in different directions and consequently decided to sell their share of the bakery and start a new one where they can continue their business journey. Iggy’s Bread of the World was established and in just six months, and no marketing, the bakery generated revenues over $1.5 million. As they became more successful, new challenges arose. Challenges included hiring new employees, assigning a management team, and making decisions concerning expansion. As they grew bigger, the Ivanovic lost control over day to day operations and new management team led by Matthew McRae – the appointed COO took over. Tensions began to rise as the new management team were looked at as outsiders who were attempting to change the culture set by the owners. Employees perceived the new management team as uncaring and inconsiderate of the family culture. The Ivanovics must thoroughly analyze the credibility and qualifications of the new management team. All new employees including any executive member is required to embrace the culture of the......

Words: 254 - Pages: 2

Birch Ppaer Case Study

...OBJECTIVE : To evaluate present organizational structure and management control system of Birch Paper Company particularly on the decentralized operations of its divisions with respect to its overall performance. PROBLEM : What effective management control system or systems should the Company adopt to attain maximum profitability not only of its divisions’ respective operations but that of the Company as a whole? AREAS OF CONSIDERATION 1. Company Background Birch Paper Company is a medium-sized, vertically integrated paper company, producing white and kraft papers and paperboard. It has four producing divisions and a timberland division which supplied part of the company’s pulp requirement; each division is operating independently headed by its respective division managers. Birch’s division managers normally were free to buy materials or inputs from whichever supplier they wished, and even on sales within the company; so divisions were expected to meet the going market price if they wanted the business. Early in the year, its Northern Division designed a special retail display box in conjunction with the Thompson Division, which was equipped to make the box. Thompson, as one of Birch’s four producing divisions converted paperboard output into corrugated boxes. It also printed and colored the outside surface of the boxes. Birch’s Southern Division will supply the lineboard and corrugating medium to Thompson Division in the event the latter got...

Words: 1696 - Pages: 7

Summary of Case

...Case #1: Brigham and Women’s/Faulkner Hospitals This case takes an in depth look into the evolving medical industry. Key aspects of this case focus on the benefits and drawbacks of a merger between large and community sized hospitals and the possible cost subsidizing that may occur and the impact the qualitative factors may play in such cases. Overview of Industry: Health Care costs began to rise while insurance reimbursements began to fall. This led to a larger amount of patients being treated on outpatient basis. This aided in temporarily curbing the costs associated with overnight patients. AMCs therefore focused on primary care as means of reducing operating costs. Thus a lot of emphasis was placed on cost control. Managed Care plans lead to capped fee for hospitals. As a result, BWH saw a drop in incoming patients. AMCs thus focused on primary care as means of reducing operating costs. Community doctors were reluctant to recommend AMC doctors, instead sent patients to less costly hospitals. The solution seemed to be pointing towards possible mergers. The mergers’ purpose was to achieve Economies of Scale and also get access to the patients and knowledge of community hospitals and fill the gap where the large hospitals lacked market penetration. OUTLINE OF BWH HOSPITAL: Largest hospital in New England. Often ranked as best in service. High end teaching hospital. Employs more than 12,000 people with 44,000 patients. Annual research budget of......

Words: 756 - Pages: 4

Case Summary

...Dawei Chen Case Summary- Confucius, Machiavelli, and Rousseau According to the Case context, we can find out many ideas about leadership. First, from the great Chinese ancient philosopher-Confucius that we can learn that a phenomenal leader needs to love people and use virtue to rule a society. The ultimate goal for a leader is to fulfill everyone’s demand. In order to achieve this goal; a leader must be a sage or at least a very wise man to set up a very extraordinary example for others to learn. However, this opinion has a very obvious flaw that people cannot be as good as he think and most people are selfish that this kind of leadership is not going to be successful. Second, From the Machiavelli, we can acquire the idea which is almost opposite from Confucius, in his eyes, people has variable characters and most people are wicked. They are selfish and the only way to rule them is to treat them like objects. To achieve this goal, most leaders need to use the power of government and use many different strategies to control his followers such as military forces and spies. The core of his theory is to make fear in people’s mind and use this fear to set up the leadership and leaders can observe other leaders to make this happen. Third, case describes the great thinker in revolution era- Rousseau. He established the basic ideas of democracy. The core idea of his “The Social Contract “is to gather the “general will” and make the general will into a contract that is the...

Words: 657 - Pages: 3

Case Summary

...Case #3/Dying, death and bereavement in social work Introduction In this case we are presented with The Florida Project for Human Justice; a nonprofit agency in downtown Tallahassee that provides legal services to inmates pro-bono. Diane Epps, executive director/attorney and Joe Moran, lead attorney for the agency has invited their co-worker Cynthia Sanders, mitigation investigator to join them in working with one of their death row clients. , Elaborate more on the case Problem Statement The team of attorneys and mitigation investigator cannot agree on whether Mr. Aranda is competent enough to make the decision of waiving his death sentence appeal or if his rights to self-determination is being violated. It is important that the team is united in their decision in order to present a solid case to the presiding. Very good problem statement Contextual Analysis The Florida Project for Human Justice is a nonprofit agency that primary mission is to represent death-sentenced inmates across the state who are appealing their sentences. The agency also advocates for clients with life sentences and for a change in state law to end the death penalty. They’re ultimate mission is to protect and sustain the lives of those on death row. The agency consists of a staff of seven with a high employee turner turn over. The work is stressful and they operate on a very limited budget. The agency is primarily devoted to appellate work and usually began providing services when the......

Words: 821 - Pages: 4

Case Summary

...claims and judicial resolution of legal cases. Your ability to achieve these objectives will be evaluated by your performance on the case briefs, class discussions, and an excruciatingly final examination. TEXTBOOK: The textbook is Cheeseman, Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International Issues, 8th ed. (ISBN 978-0-13-289041-0). COURSE ASSIGNMENTS: (1) You must turn in a case brief (i.e., a one-page “executive summary”) each week from Meeting #2 through Meeting #14, inclusive; (2) Lead (when designated by instructor) and participate in weekly class discussions of the cases; and (3) Take an excruciatingly difficult final exam. Each brief must be done in the style and format described at pp. 5-9, below, with the following modifications: a brief may not exceed 1 page, with one-inch margins all the way around, at least 1.5 spacing, and at least 10-point font. To earn an “A,” logic, clarity, cogency, and interest must be evident. An “A” paper must be neatly typed, with virtually no errors in grammar, spelling, and style. A “B” paper will be well-written but will lack the “spark” of an “A” paper and may contain errors. A “C” paper will contain errors and be poorly written and/or organized. Lower grades are awarded for sub-standard papers. Late papers will be penalized according to the following formula: [(awarded points)(.97n)], where “n” = number of days late. You may work together to analyze and brief the cases, but each brief must be......

Words: 1642 - Pages: 7

Case Summary

...This case describes a decision facing the officers of the Solidarity Fund, a large pension fund operated by the Quebec Federation of Labor (QFL).The QFL had founded the Fund to provide members of its affiliated unions and others access to professionally managed retirement accounts. It also sought to create job growth in the province of Quebec and to support companies with good working conditions, positive relations with local communities, and a commitment to environmental responsibility. The goal of QFL was to extend access to manage retirement account for its members and to instill job growth. Another focus of the QFL was to support socially responsible companies that carried out their due diligence process successfully and paid special attention to employee working conditions. The controversy stemmed from the fact the Gildan Active wear and Montreal based textile and Garment that started in 1984 managed and operated three factories. Gildan owned and operated three factories and in effort to compete with Hanes and Fruit of the Loom, Gildan began to expand in 1995, Gildan contacted the Solidarity Fund for help in financing its expansion. Gildan grew drastically and even expanded some production to Honduras. Gildan believed that Honduras was the reason for its success as 80% of the jobs were held by women between the ages of 18 and 25. In 2002, the basic minimum hourly wage was 63 cents. An employee in Montreal earned more in one hour than a Honduran did in one day. The......

Words: 328 - Pages: 2

Birch Paper Company Case

...set up as to benefit the Thompson Division, since their profits will be lower. The bid from the Thompson division is in the best interest of Birch Paper Co. Since the Thompson division is a part of the Birch Paper Co., buying from them leads to less money coming from out of their pocket. Even though the price is technically higher, the actual cost is lower because a portion of the money stays in the company and is not part of their out of pocket costs. As a result, the company as a whole is more profitable. Lead time is also a factor to acknowledge, as Birch Paper Co would be able to purchase the products sooner, track the products easier, and receive the products in a timely fashion. If they were to outsource, this would not be the case. The VP should intervene in the situation because the company’s profitability is at stake. If the VP would not intervene then top management would accept the lowest bid, although the lowest bid does not benefit the company as a whole. While this example is less than 5% of total volume, the reason the VP needs to intervene is because it could have adverse effects in the future if similar issues arise between division profits versus company profits. By hiring the Thompson division, the company as a whole saves money even though the profits in the Thompson division will be smaller. Without the Birch Paper Co. there are no divisions, thus what’s best for the company is best for each division....

Words: 308 - Pages: 2

Case Summary

...aExecutive Summary The case gives an idea about how the competition influenced Jollibee's strategy, both domestic and international. Jollibee ,which was a Filipino chain of restaurants, was forced to change their strategy with the entry of McDonalds in Philippines, which later transformed the company into a global company .The company faced serious challenges with their international exposure. The challenges included the conflicts with franchisees/Joint venture and conflicts between divisions. Another issue that the company faced was the entry into Papa New Guinea, United States of America and expansion plans in Hong Kong. The company has to consider the financial instability it faces while considering their plans. In the analysis we have tried to cover the effectiveness of strategies adopted by Mr Tony Kitchner (Former International Division head). This case analysis report deals with, firstly the key management challenges faced by the company, followed by some supporting arguments. In the management issues, the report focuses into the conflicting areas or the need to establish a greater cooperation and coordination between the Domestic and International divisions. Then, the recommendations regarding what should the company do differently in each of its department like in Marketing, HR, Finance or Operations, to succeed in its plans of global expansion. Finally, the feasibility of the three decisions that the new management has taken is also discussed. We have also tried...

Words: 6626 - Pages: 27

Birch Case

...Case Study – Birch Paper Company Company Background: Birch Paper Company was a medium-sized, partly integrated paper company. It had four producing divisions, namely Northern Division, Thompson Division, Southern Division & one unnamed Division and a Timberland Division. Birch Paper was producing white and kraft papers and paperboard. A portion of its paperboard output was converted into corrugated boxes by the Thompson Division, which was also printed and colored the outside surface of the boxes. [pic] Birch’s division managers normally were free to buy materials or inputs from whichever supplier they wished, and even on sales within the company; so divisions were expected to meet the going market price if they wanted the business. Early in the year, its Northern Division designed a special retail display box in conjunction with the Thompson Division, which was equipped to make the box. Thompson, as one of Birch’s four producing divisions converted paperboard output into corrugated boxes. It also printed and colored the outside surface of the boxes. Birch’s Southern Division will supply the liner board and corrugating medium to Thompson Division in the event the latter got the order from Northern. Company policies: The management implemented a policy of decentralizing responsibility and authority for all divisions except those relating to overall company policy.   Each division was judged independently on the basis of its profit and return on investment.    ......

Words: 2482 - Pages: 10

Case Summary

...Extended case study Australian Beverages Ltd—Pre-seen case study information A - Introduction to Australian Beverages Ltd - 1937, Australian Beverages Ltd (ABL) commenced manufacturing soft drinks [non-alcoholic drinks rather than ‘hard’ drinks that contain alcohol]. - 1970s and 1980s, the company expanded beverage portfolio by entering into other non-alcoholic beverage categories, such as fruit- and milkbased drinks. - 2011, the company was Australia’s largest supplier of non-alcoholic beverages. - -Tom Dwyer, current Managing Director since 2008. - Joined the company at a time when carbonated soft drinks (CSDs) growth was stagnating and shareholder confidence in the company was waning. - Dwyer established a strategic planning team to assess the current product portfolio and identify organic and acquisition growth opportunities. - From this review the importance of operational excellence was identified - Strong investment was made in world-class manufacturing facilities and systems. - Process re-engineering was implemented to reduce the costs of manufacturing and time-to-market. - Given the declining consumption of CSDs, Tom Dwyer has sought to reduce ABL’s reliance on them, focusing on growing new products and entering new non-alcoholic beverage Categories. - Significant investment in product development of other non-alcoholic beverages - Several acquisitions made to grow the market share of non-CSD based beverages in the company’s......

Words: 6430 - Pages: 26