Critically Assess the Claim That Religious Language Is Meaningless

In: Religion Topics

Submitted By Nenna
Words 367
Pages 2
AO1
Candidates may begin with an account of the work of the Logical Positivists, possibly even giving an account of the forming of the Vienna Circle and the writings which led these philosophers to come together. Some may mention Wittgenstein’s Tractatus but they should be aware that he was not himself a member of the Circle.
This may lead to an exploration of the strengths and weaknesses of the Verification Principle, with some demonstration of the self-refuting nature of the principle itself. Some may use examples from religious language of the kinds of statements which the Vienna circle were accusing of meaninglessness such as; ‘God is all-loving, all powerful, your God is a jealous God.’
Some candidates may take their arguments towards an explanation of the later writings of Wittgenstein and introduce the ideas of language games; and his claim that language gets its meaning from the context in which it is used or the rules of the game you are playing at any given time.
Others may explore the approach taken by the Vienna Circle to analytic and synthetic statements, explaining the need for synthetic statements to be verifiable by empirical evidence if they were to be considered meaningful. In this context some may address the issue of strong and weak verification.
AO2
In their evaluation candidates may assess the underlying assumption of Logical Positivism that it is only scientific propositions which can accurately describe the reality of our world. Arguably not religious language but also poetry and music contribute a great deal to our understanding of reality. Who would say that a Shakespearean sonnet tells us nothing about the world?
Others may assess the extent to which Wittgenstein helped to make all kinds of language meaningful again by his introduction of language games. They may discuss the extent to which he only allowed for communication within…...

Similar Documents

Critically Assess the Claim That We Live in a ‘Globalised World’. Use Evidence to Support Your Discussion

...“Critically assess the claim that we live in a ‘globalised world’. Use evidence to support your discussion.” When looking at globalisation we have to realise that it isn’t just one thing, the word globalisation isn’t just one meaning, it isn’t just an economic or cultural concept and it doesn’t just affect these, it also effects a lot of other relations. It can be anything from personal to structural things and this can affect us on many different levels, as well as economic and cultural there are also environmental concerns and effects on the globe which now need global solutions. This is essay is going to explore the aspects of globalisation and assess analytically and critically how we are now supposed to live in a “globalised word” and to what extent that it is actually true, using evidence and examples from sociological scholars and every day samples to support different idea’s which are for and against this notion. Globalisation means cultures and economics are now becoming more the same, more homogenous and throughout this essay this will be challenged on how this effects the world we live in not just in Britain but in all other countries too. Globalisation is involved with dissolving boarders and making them less strict and more flexible, this allowing us to have growing global connections, something which is called interconnectedness. We can now receive information from across the world almost instantly this giving exercise and organisation of power on a global......

Words: 2205 - Pages: 9

Humanists Claims That the Meaning of a Thing Is Inherent in the Thing Itself, and That Language Simply Labels What Already Exists. Poststructuralists, on the Other Hand, Argue That Naming Is Constitutive. Critically

...Humanists claims that the meaning of a thing is inherent in the thing itself, and that language simply labels what already exists. Poststructuralists, on the other hand, argue that naming is constitutive. Critically analyze these competing perspectives and the arguments that are made in support of them. Humanism is essentially a belief system that is dictated by the way in which humans themselves, react, produce, and perform things. It is “the basic value system of humans…providing the fact that humanism is a human-centered system of meaning making”(Fuery & Mansfield, 2000; 209). In reference to the proposed argument, a humanist would see an object as a production of the human, and the language associated with that object is merely for convenience sake, to reiterate what said object is. This argument is reaffirmed by the concept of the existential self. This provides us with the view that we are separate and distinguishable from other objects and other people, which in turn suggests that whilst we interact with other humans and objects we are able to distinguish what and whom we are interacting with based on our own personal human development. “Humanisms are based on creating a system of meaning with man as its centre.”( R.Baltmann, 1982. P174) This is of course ‘man’ in the most general sense, as a collective. In order for people to gain meaning from such individualistic societies generalisations need to be made. It is impossible for a society to create an easily......

Words: 942 - Pages: 4

Religious and Ethical Language Are About Facts. Discuss.

...Religious and Ethical Language are about facts. Discuss. In order to analyse whether language, religious or ethical are about facts it is vital to define facts. According to Honderich a fact can be defined as the worldly correlation of a true proposition, in other words a state of affairs make a statement true or false. There are two main schools of thought as to how ethical and religious language is to be treated. The cognitivists argue that statements about religion and ethics possess truth value, and hence can be known. As such the case such statements can be about facts. For example ‘Hitler is evil’ or ‘God exists’ is knowable in the sense that it corresponds to events that are occurring in the world. This view presents the correspondence theory of truth, which is what has now become to be known as early Wittgenstein’s writings. It argues that statements are true so far as in it paints a picture about the world it must relate to and derive meaning out of. As such the case religious and ethical truths are to be discovered. Ethical naturalists such as F.H. Bradley have argued that ethical language is about facts of the world. It is argued that moral statements which are subjective statements about values can be translated into facts or objective statements of fact. Thus it can be argued that ‘Hitler is evil’ is a true statement on the account that he was responsible for mass murder. This view was challenged by Hume. Hume argued that it is not possible to move......

Words: 1514 - Pages: 7

Assess the Claim That There Are Objective Moral Statements

...false. A strong case for moral realism is the fact that most people would agree that when we say statements such as ‘slavery is wrong’ or ‘abortion is right’ we are giving a statement which would normally be taken as true or false. For example when we say ‘slavery is wrong’ we are asserting the idea that enslaving people has the moral property of being wrong, this fits into commonly used language in the way that other statements such as ‘my car is blue’ function in a similar way; we asserting the idea that the car has the property of being blue. However an emotivist might argue that all human language is misleading, and this therefore means that moral realists don’t have much evidence for this claim. For example when we say ‘the four corners of the Earth’ we are using an idiom, which is a literary technique used to describe something in a figurative way. As we are aware that the Earth is not flat but in fact elliptical, we know it cannot possibly have four corners. Yet we still insist on using terms such as this to describe things, making them in a way misleading. Furthermore in ordinary language it is common to talk about the mind as though it exists, however eliminative materialists believe that the mind does not exist at all. Just because moral statements can be either true or false, it does not necessarily amount to any of them actually being true. This could be joined in with the idea of error theory. Error theory states that moral statements do have a truth value, but......

Words: 1458 - Pages: 6

Critically Assess the Relationship Between, Gender, Religious Participation and Religious Organisations (33 Mark)

...Critically assess the relationship between, gender, religious participation and religious organisations (33 Mark) Statistics have shown that women tent to be more religious than men across most cultures globally. This is reflected by the Church Census records as it shows that participation in churches and denominations in England and Wales between 1979 and 2005 women were consistently more likely to attend. There are various reasons why females are more religious than men ranging from socialization, exploitation to patriarchy in traditional religions. Women’s sexuality has always been a dangerous factor in religion; this is because women menstruate and give birth they are considered to have a great capacity to pollute religious rituals. This can be seen in the Adam and Eve story in Christianity as Eve has ‘seduced’ Adam in order to eat the apple which God had forbidden to do so. This shows that the presence of a female can distract men from performing religious rituals and worshipping God. Bird argues that sexuality is an important factor in many religions. In Roman Catholic churches priests are expected to be celibate meaning they have to deliberately refrain from sexual activity while in other religions such as Islam are opposed to homosexuality. This means that in order for priests to carry out their duty appropriately there needs to be a degree of policing of the body; and the presence of women makes it more difficult. Due to patriarchal ideologies women have......

Words: 2244 - Pages: 9

Critically Assess the Effects of Corporate Separate Personality.

...Critically assess the effects of corporate separate personality. The fundamental concept of corporate separate personality recognises that a company, once incorporated, becomes a ‘body corporate’, i.e. a legal entity distinct from its members and officers. The various effects of corporate separate personality shall be dealt with in turn. 1) Distinct legal identity from its members One of the most significant effects of corporate separate personality is that the company assumes a separate identity from that of its members. Even if a company is owned outright by one shareholder, the company has a completely separate personality from that individual. This is confirmed by the leading case of Salomon v A. Salomon & Co Ltd in which the House of Lords held that the company’s acts were its own acts, not those of Mr Salomon personally. As a result, Mr Salomon was not personally liable for his company’s debts. It is worth noting, however, that the Court did recognise that there would be situations in which they would be prepared to move away from that principle and ‘lift the veil of incorporation’ and find individuals liable where they had acted dishonestly, fraudulently or unreasonably. 2) Limited liability Due to the fact that the company is a separate legal individual, it follows that its members will not generally be liable for its debts and obligations. This gives the shareholders a great level of security, since it means that they are able to profit from the successes of the...

Words: 1123 - Pages: 5

Critically Assess the Claim That Religious Language Is Meaningless?

...Critically assess the claim that religious language is meaningless? Many philosophers have argued as to whether or not the ways in which we speak about religion are relevant or meaningful. This issue of religious language looks at the way we talk about God, debate ideas and communicate our theist or atheist ideologies. For some, religious language is meaningful and full of purpose while others see it to being incomprehensible and pointless. The verification principle a theory proposed by A.J. Ayer is a key argument, which addresses whether religious language is meaningful or not. Ayer was one of the logical positivists, a Viennese group of philosophers who were inspired by the theories of the early Wittgenstein and he sought to answer what makes a statement ‘meaningful’ as opposed to what makes it ‘true’. Ayer begins his thesis with the claim that language is only meaningful if it can be verified by a sense-observation. If you cannot demonstrate with sense-observations how a statement is true, then the statement is factually meaningless. A ‘putative proposition’ is the name Ayer gives to statements yet to be verified. A putative statement is either verifiable practically or in principle. For instance, a statement such as “that is a red car” is verifiable in practice by looking at the car. However, a statement such as “There is life in another universe” is verifiable in principle but not in practice, as we possess insufficient technology. Therefore Ayer then makes......

Words: 1356 - Pages: 6

‘the Theory of Language Games Does Not Solve the Problems of Religious Language.’ How Far Do You Agree? (20)

...Jamie Smith  ‘The theory of language games does not solve the problems of religious  language.’  How far do you agree? (20)    Wittgenstein originally supported logical positivists, but then came to reject the  verification principle. His argument is that the meanings of words are in their use, the  function they perform as agreed on by the group using them. He states that each  activity has its own language and shows this in his toolbox analogy ­ the items in the  toolbox (hammers etc) are all tools, but without knowing the specific use and function of  the tools, their understanding is superficial.   He argues that this can be seen in religious language. Language games exist in all  forms of human activity and life, but people not in the game will be unable to understand  the use of this language. If people don’t understand the language then it will seem  meaningless. Religious belief has its own language and a non­believer will find that  because they aren't in the game it is meaningless to them. An outsider can’t claim that  because they don’t understand the language or the game doesn’t make it any less  meaningful, it just doesn’t make sense to them.    I agree with the statement to certain extent. Wittgenstein argues there is a system for  which religious believers can use language as a valid form of evidence towards their  faith and God, and  language games supports this. However, this approach doesn't help ......

Words: 593 - Pages: 3

Critically Assess the Effect of Social Media on Society

...Critically assess the effect of Social Media on society Social media as defined by Andreas M and Michael (2010, p. 61) is “a group of Internet-based applications that build on the ideological and technological foundations of Web 2.0, and that allow the creation and exchange of user-generated content.” Social media platforms include chat rooms, blogging web sites, social networking sites, forums, and also text messages and e-mail (Luxton, June and Fairall, 2012). The most popular social networking site, Facebook has made such an influence on society that from 2004 to 2011 the number of users registered to the site increased from 1 million to about 1 billion users worldwide (Yahoo Finance, 2012). With such vast figures social media is bound to have an impact on the way society operates, either positively or negatively, or both. These will be critically analyzed in this essay, identifying the most crucial impacts it has on our society. With the rapid increase in the awareness and use of social networking sites, it has provided positive contributions to how society functions. First and foremost, social networking has grown to become a critical part of a business’s marketing strategies, and if managed efficiently, will prove to be a major factor for its success. Social media networks such as Facebook and Twitter have provided an easy-to-access platform for people to share their views, preferences, and experiences about brands and products. Once this information gets widespread......

Words: 3119 - Pages: 13

Critically Assess the Claims and Conclusions on William James’ Variety of Religious Experiences

...William James was a philosopher and psychologist from New York City.In the book ‘the varieties of religious experience’, James concluded that religious experience testifies that “we can experience union with something larger that ourselves and in that union find our greatest peace”. He defined such experiences as “experiences of the divine” and believed that religious experience was at the heart of religion, true religion unlike religious teachings, practices and attitudes as these, for James are ‘second hand’ religion which later develops as individuals reflect on their common experience. It is the actual experience which points to God. However this theory does little to prove religious experiences simply because many of his claims do not stand up to critical analysis. James looked at a variety of religious experiences, particularly mystical experiences, this refers to experiences where God is revealed directly and there is a sense of oneness with the divine. James claimed that there are 4 criteria which are all characteristics of mystical experiences. Firstly an experience has to be ineffable, meaning that it is beyond proper description as it cannot adequately be described in words, language limitations prevent description. It also must be noetic, not just feelings but however the experience gives you a deep and direct knowledge of God which could not have been achieved through reason alone. Another criteria of mystical experience is that it must be transient, the......

Words: 1295 - Pages: 6

: Critically Assess the Declining Power in Parliaments

...Government Assignment Essay Title: Critically assess the declining power in Parliaments GV1102 Assignment Topic 2: Critically assess three reasons for the declining power of parliaments. Introduction Throughout the past few centuries, political structure and life has been changing ever so rapidly, so too has the power that parliaments possess. This decline in power is due to a number of reasons, but mainly through the power of the lay person. Nowadays, people outside of parliament have huge power and can have a rather large influence in decisions that are made within parliaments. People power aside, Government decisions are also influenced in other ways such as, mass media, European Union decisions and disciplined political parties. All of these issues dominate the Irish political landscape from week to week, and are becoming more prevalent since the Economic Crash of 2008/2009 and the IMF Bailout that followed it on that infamous November night of 2010. Since then, every move the Irish Government makes is not only being monitored by the Irish people but it is also scrutinised by the European Union and the huge influence of the media. Another issue which detracts from the power of parliaments is the workings of the traditional Political Party system, although politicians may sound to be very passionate on a subject, they may find it very hard to act on this unless their political party is in agreement. The idea of Diciplined Political Parties hasn’t gone......

Words: 1602 - Pages: 7

Religious Language Is Meaningless. Discuss (35)

...Religious language is the lexis used to describe or discuss views in relation to religion. Religious language has many different forms and expresses multiple meanings encompassing a variety of situations such as worship, practice, dogma and doctrine. This however means religious language is subjective and raises debate over whether it is meaningless or not. A collection of philosophers, the logical positivists, formulated the verification principle, which was developed by A. J. Ayer in order to combat the idea that religious language is meaningful. He thought that “God talk” was nonsense because it could not be verified analytically or synthetically. They believed that there were only 2 types of statements which are meaningful; tautologies (true by definition) and statements that can be verified by some kind of test. Following this theory, religious language is deemed meaningless because they believed it was metaphysical and there is no way to even test whether God exists. A. J. Ayer stated that there are 2 types of the verification princip0le. The first is strong verification, which is something we can verify for ourselves and the second is weak verification which relies on other people to verify it. John Hick was one of the main critics of the verification principle. He believed that we can’t write off all statements as meaningless. He put forward the idea of eschatological verification, saying that some things we will be able to verify after death, therefore we......

Words: 629 - Pages: 3

Between 1547 and 1558 England Was Almost Torn Apart by Religious Revolution. Assess the Validity of This Claim. (45 Marks)

...arguable that a religious revolution took place in England between 1547 and 1558, during which time there were two monarchs – Edward VI and Mary I, with opposing religious beliefs. During Tudor England, religious identity was extremely important, and therefore religious ‘revolution’ was going to affect the people, and the country significantly. Edward VI came to power in 1547, at the age of just nine, and therefore he was assigned a ‘protectorate’ and in the first half of his reign it was his Uncle, the Duke of Somerset. Somerset did himself appear to be Protestant, welcoming religious radicals such as John Hooper and Thomas Becon into his household. He also made a start on reforming religion; in July 1547 he introduced the Book of Homilies and paraphrases, a religious document that had to be placed in every Church. And in December 1547 the Act of Six Articles was repealed, it had been a document that re-established Catholic Doctrines. All of these policies were reforming religion and moving towards the Protestant way of running the Church, and Edward hoped that the introduction of Protestant readings, for example the Cranmer’s first prayer book in 1548, would lead people to begin to convert to Protestantism. After Somerset fell from power, religious revolution progressed further under John Dudley, the Duke of Northumberland. Despite originally being more conservative himself, and supporting that side of the Privy Council, he understood the need for religious reform under......

Words: 1455 - Pages: 6

Critically Assess the Claim That All People Are Free to Make Moral Decisions. (35 Marks)

...Critically assess the claim that all people are free to make moral decisions. (35 marks) Free will in making moral decisions is a much disputed topic. Many philosophers argue that there is no such thing as free will and everything is predetermined, while others dispute this and say that we have complete freedom to of what we wish. Doing as we wish is a key aspect of what defines free will. Hume defined liberty as ‘a power of acting or not acting, according to the determinations of the will’. This means that for a decision to be free, it must be solely of our own desires and not due to an external influence. Libertarianism is one theory that would agree with the claim that all humans are free to make moral decisions. Libertarianism is the idea that humans have complete free will. The Uncertainty principle, developed by Dr Heisenberg, discusses how the world and universe are unpredictable and indeterminable. This is used to back up libertarianism as we cannot know what is going to happen, when or where. Heisenberg also said that ‘ When we now the present precisely, we can predict the future’. However we do not know the present precisely and therefore anything could happen in the future which reinforces the idea of free will. In terms of making moral decisions, Libertarianism places moral responsibility upon the person who makes the decision. Nothing else but their own desires influences them, therefore only they can be held accountable, meaning that they must accept any......

Words: 835 - Pages: 4

Critically Assess the Via Negativa as a Means of Knowing God

...Critically assess the Via Negativa as a means of knowing God In the Christian tradition, the via negativa (apophatic theology) refers to a way of speaking about God and his attributes through the way of the negative. Because God is beyond our capacity as human beings to comprehend, anything we can say of him is necessarily limited by our finite human understanding and his reality far surpasses our power of expression through our anthropocentric languages. It suggests that the closest way we can get to describing him is by saying what he is not, rather than what he is. We therefore can come to know God better through meditating on how much greater he is than anything we can conceive for as St. Thomas said: “This is the ultimate in human knowledge of God: to know that we do not know Him”. According to this way, we use words like “infinite,” “incorporeal”, “immutable,” and “ineffable” to describe God. Even to call God “perfect,” says St. Thomas, we do by way of negation, because we understand perfection as “lacking nothing.” Moses Maimonides believed that when it came to directly describing God’s nature, “silence is the best praise” and that even the Torah was an imperfect source for describing God as any descriptions are carried out using human language (“The Torah was written by the sons of men”). However he understood human need to describe and explain the characteristics of God, which he felt was impossible to do in a meaningful way; And so he suggested that we demonstrate......

Words: 1244 - Pages: 5