Duty Based

In: Business and Management

Submitted By mz2lovely
Words 474
Pages 2
Duty-Based and Outcome-Based Ethics

Ethical reasoning is the process by which an individual examines a situation according to his or her moral convictions or ethical standards. Fundamental ethical reasoning approaches include: Duty-based ethics and Outcome-based ethics.
Duty-based ethics weigh the end of an action against the means used to attain the end. Duty based ethics are based upon an underlying concept of duty regardless of the consequences of action taken or forsworn in keeping with duty. It generally arises from religious belief of philosophy reasoning. Ethical standards based on duty may also be derived from philosophical principles such as the Kantian philosophy. A central postulate in kantian ethics is that it should evaluate their actions in light of the consequences that follows if everyone in society acted in the same way.
In duty-based ethics the categorical imperative can be applied to any action when deciding whether an action is ethical. To determine whether an action is ethical one should consider what the effect would be if everyone similarly situated acted in the same way. Categorical imperative ethics maintains that a decision should be made without trying to predict whether an action will create the greatest balance of good over evil. Ethics in the categorical imperative sense is a function of moral rules and principles and does not involve any calculation of the consequences.
Although a duty cannot exist without a corresponding right, duty-based ethical standards imply that human beings have basic rights. In order to decide whether an action is ethical in the principle of rights one should consider what effect her actions would have on the fundamental rights of others (Miller,2013,p.52) Natural law tradition embraces the concept that certain things (killing) are morally wrong, they are contrary to human nature. Those who believe in…...

Similar Documents

Fiduciary Duties

...FIDUCIARY DUTIES AND OTHER RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATE DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS Morrison & Foerster LLP Christopher M. Forrester Celeste S. Ferber RR DONNELLEY EZ START XBRL We Tag. You Validate. We File. With the release of the proposed rule, the SEC will require the use of XBRL for financial reporting starting as early as 2009 for some companies. RR Donnelley is uniquely qualified to give you guidance on how your company can prepare for the SEC mandate. As the market leader in XBRL filings, we have been helping leading companies successfully tag and file XBRL financials since the inception of the SEC Voluntary Filing Program. RR Donnelley’s proven EZ Start XBRL full-service solution is designed to save you crucial time. With EZ Start, we do the initial tagging for you, reducing the time spent mapping and validating XBRL tags to under ten hours. Our goal is to transfer knowledge to your financial team to ensure a firm understanding of the taxonomies, mapping process and SEC requirements. To learn more, visit www.tryxbrl.com. FIDUCIARY DUTIES AND OTHER RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATE DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP Christopher M. Forrester Celeste S. Ferber RR Donnelley Global Capital Markets Copyright© 2008 Morrison & Foerster LLP (No claim to original U.S. Government works) All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic...

Words: 49138 - Pages: 197

Segregation of Duties

...Segregation of Duties One element of IT audit is to audit the IT function. While there are many important aspects of the IT function that need to be addressed in an audit or risk assessment, the fundamental element of internal control is the segregation of certain key duties, especially as it relates to risk. The basic idea underlying segregation of duties (SOD) is that no single employee should be in a position both to perpetrate and to conceal errors or fraud in the normal course of their duties. Similar to traditional SOD in accounting functions, SOD in IT plays a major role in reducing certain risk, and does so in a similar fashion as well. Duties that should be segregated include: 1. Custody of the assets 2. Authorization 3. Recording transactions If adequate segregation of duties does not exist, the following could occur: 1. Misappropriation of assets 2. Misstated financial statements 3. Inaccurate financial documentation (i.e. errors or irregularities) 4. Improper use of funds or modification of data could go undetected 5. Unauthorized or erroneous changes or modification of data and programs may not be detected As the figure 1 shows, there are some of the key roles and functions that need to be segregated. 1. IT Duties vs. User Departments The most basic segregation is the segregation of the duties of the IT function from user departments. Generally speaking, this means the user department does not perform its own IT duties. While a department......

Words: 2548 - Pages: 11

Director Duties

...company as well as shareholders. Directors are basically fiduciary agents and they owe duties to the company, directors' are appointed by the company's shareholders to run the company's affairs for the benefits of the shareholders. Moreover, no company can get success without having the good and honest directors, so company success can only be achieved, if the directors of the company fulfil their duties and complete enforcement of the director's duties. Therefore directors play very significant role in any corporate governance system. Director's general duties are based on the certain common law rules and equitable principles. Lord Judge Bowen explains director's duties in these beautiful words that “directors are described sometimes as agents, sometimes as trustees and sometimes as managing partners. But each of this expression is to be used not as exhaustive of their powers and responsibilities, but indicating useful points of view from which they may for the moment and for the particular purpose be considered.” The Chapter 1 of this paper is amid to critically analyze that what are the duties and responsibilities of directors under Companies Act 2006. The duties of directors alone are of no importance if they cannot be fully enforced, the chapter 2 of this piece of work relates to the system of enforcement which provides the different kind of controls which gives assurance than how these duties of directors are implemented. Basically Common law provides three ways of......

Words: 8848 - Pages: 36

Duties of an Nco

...As a noncommissioned officer, you have duties, responsibilities and authority DUTY: A duty is something you must do by virtue of your position and is a legal or moral obligation. For example, it is the supply sergeant's duty to issue equipment and keep records of the unit's supplies. It is the first sergeant's duty to hold formations, instruct platoon sergeants and assist the commander in supervising unit operations. It is the duty of the squad/section/team leader to account for his soldiers and ensure that they receive necessary instructions and are properly trained to perform their jobs. A noncommissioned officer's duties are numerous and must be taken seriously. An NCO's duty includes taking care of soldiers, which is your priority. Corporals and sergeants do this by developing a genuine concern for their soldiers' well-being. Leaders must know and understand their soldiers well enough to train them as individuals and teams to operate proficiently. This will give them confidence in their ability to perform well under the difficult and demanding conditions of battle. Individual training is the principle duty and responsibility of NCOs. No one in the Army has more to do with training soldiers than NCOs. Well trained soldiers will likely succeed and survive on the battlefield. Well trained soldiers properly do the tasks their NCOs give them. A good leader executes the boss's decisions with energy and enthusiasm; looking at their leader, soldiers will believe the......

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Separation of Duties

...Importance of Separation of Duties Student CMGT/430 Date Professor The Importance of Separation of Duties Introduction Riordan Manufacturing is one of the industry leaders in the field of plastic molding injection. The company headquarters office is in San Jose, California and has three other plants, including one international location. The list of locations includes Albany, Georgia, Pontiac, Michigan and Hangzhou, China. The San Jose, California, location serves as the company’s headquarters and the home of their research and development. The Albany, Georgia, plant produces beverage containers. The Pontiac, Michigan, location produces custom plastic parts. The international location in Hangzhou, China, produces custom plastic fan parts. Riordan employs 550 people and have projected annual earnings of $46 million. The purpose of this proposal, submitted by Smith Consulting, is to advise Riordan Manufacturing on the best practice to secure the company network after evaluating the company network and what steps are necessary to set forth enterprise security policies via segregating duties of employees by role assignments. Minimizing Risk The goal of any company should be to successfully minimize their risk and optimize their profitability. To accomplishing this progress is to examine their current network for shortfalls that allow security breaches, theft by client or employee and to minimized possible......

Words: 782 - Pages: 4

Duty of Care

...RE: Determination of Whether the Bridge School Owed Al-Fulani, its student, a Duty of Care I. Introduction Kahlil Al-Fulani (“Al-Fulani”) is a 20-year-old Lebanese-American student who currently attends the Bridge School. On September 21, 2001 Lou Gaines (“Gaines”), a fellow student, assaulted Al-Fulani in an unsupervised school lounge. This memorandum addresses whether the Bridge School owed a duty of care to prevent Gaines’s assault on Al-Fulani. A court will likely conclude that the Bridge School owed a duty of care to Al-Fulani because of its special relationship with him and because the harm was foreseeable. II. Question Presented Whether the Bridge School owed Al-Fulani a duty of care given the school’s supervisory responsibility over student conduct and surroundings, knowledge of Gaines’s targeted harassment of Al-Fulani and recent wave of national violence towards Arab-American students after the World Trade Center attack, and Al-Fulani’s age? III. Brief Answer A court will likely conclude that the Bridge School owed Al-Fulani a duty of care. The law imposes a duty of care on schools when (1) a special relationship exists between the school and student and (2) the harm is foreseeable. Leger v. Stockton Unified Sch. Dist., 202 Cal. App. 3d 1448, 1453-54 (1988). A special relationship between a school and student is created when a school assumes the responsibility to supervise the conduct and control the environment of students, who do not do......

Words: 2231 - Pages: 9

Three Ethical Approaches Based on Virtue, Duty and Consequence

...THREE ETHICAL APPROACHES BASED ON VIRTUE, DUTY AND CONSEQUENCE Three ethical approaches have evolved as the focus of those who study moral philosophy: virtue ethics, duty ethics and consequential ethics. Virtue ethics, associating ethics with personal habits, is associated with Aristotle. Duty ethics is associated with religious beliefs, although Kant tried to create a system of duties independent of belief in God. Consequential ethics is associated with the quest for rationalism during the Enlightenment, and especially with the Utilitarians. Virtue Ethics Plato and especially later Aristotle described moral behavior as “what the moral or virtuous person does.” The virtuous person develops a sense of right and wrong. This idea endures. We look to people we think of as ethical to give us advice on an ethical issue because such people have a sense of right and wrong. Aristotle tried to take the idea further, with less success. He thought that virtuous behavior meant people realizing their potential. He suggested that virtue was tied to moderation, a middle way between excess and deficiency. This idea is in practice not proven so helpful because where the midpoint is depends on where we put the extremes.[2] For example if an extreme drinker is someone who drinks six liters a day of vodka, then is three liters a day a moderate drinker? Markets operate without depending on the virtue of the business people who trade in them. But in practice ethical behavior is......

Words: 2724 - Pages: 11

Duty of Care

...Employer’s Care of Duty Dwen Guydon Strayer University LEG500: Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance Prof. Phylanice Nash, J.D. August 4, 2011 1. Explain whether Jake’s actions are in or out of “his scope of employment.” According to the definition given by USLegal.com, scope of employment refers to a person actively involved in an employment task at a particular time, usually an issue when an accident occurs, which is required to make a claim for work-related injury under state Worker's Compensation Acts (Scope of employment law & legal definitions, n.d., para.1). Workers’ Compensation reported by Terry Halbert and Elaine Ingulli, (2010) is a program which employers are required to make payments to employees who are injured during the course of their employment, regardless of negligence or fault (pp. 376). For example, based on the video, Jake, the service manager for Rally Motors, cuts his thumb while performing a complete car inspection for the customers. Although Jake was told to only perform the free oil changes by his boss, he owes a duty of care to the customers because he is a certified mechanic. He must complete the oil change and check the basic systems, such as the brakes, tires, and transmission, according to the Automotive Service Excellence (ASE) standards. As a certified mechanic, he must make sure each car is thoroughly inspected and nothing is wrong before leaving the shop. Jake’s and the company’s reputation depend upon how well he performs......

Words: 971 - Pages: 4

Fiduciary Duties

...In the essay given, it identifies fiduciary duties of directors as the main issue. There are a few consequences of breaching fiduciary duties. Under general law, a failure to disclose a conflict of interest rendered the transaction voidable at the option of the company. Aside from rescinding the contract, the company can seek to obtain a range of remedies such as an injunction to stop the breach of duty continuing, a constructive trust over assets acquired arising from the breach of duty, an account of profits to strip away gains made by the breach of the duty or equitable compensation. For contraventions of the statutory duties, both ss182 and 183 are civil penalty provisions under s1317E. Therefore, breach of these provisions may result in a declaration of contravention being made by the court and thereafter ASIC may apply for a pecuniary penalty order (s1317G) and/or a disqualification order (s206C) and/or compensation for the company (s1317H). A serious contravention of ss182 or 183 which is dishonest or reckless may result in a criminal liability under s184 (2). This action may be taken by ASIC and/or the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. The word ‘fiduciary’ has its roots in the Latin word fiducia, which means trust or confidence. A fiduciary duty is a legal duty to act solely in another party’s interest. Parties owing this duty are called fiduciaries. The individuals to whom they owe a duty to are called principals. Fiduciaries may not profit from their...

Words: 3556 - Pages: 15


...withstand more snow than Cortez… Rico more than Dolores… and Telluride more than Rico. Why Roof Trusses? Trusses are used in a variety of applications where a lightweight, yet strong, structure is required. Trusses are used extensively in bridges, buildings (particularly roofing and flooring), radio and television towers, and space-based constructions. Many home builders order prefabricated roof trusses from a manufacturer and have them delivered to a building site because building roof trusses is labor intensive and prefabricated roof trusses save time, materials, and money. 5 Advantages to using Roof Trusses: 1. Carpenters with less experience can set trusses, lowering labor costs. 2. Fewer interior load bearing walls are needed due to the trusses’ longer free span. 3. Shorter lengths of stock 2×4 are used to build trusses, reducing material prices. 4. Structural engineers design and certify roof trusses. 5. Trusses can usually be set in 1 day, meaning the interior of the home is exposed to the weather for a minimal amount of time. Roof Truss Considerations When considering roof trusses for your home, they should not be chosen based on looks alone – an experienced architect, engineer, or truss designer usually helps to determine the roof truss design best suited to the building under construction. Someone with training specific to roof trusses will be able to make the most use of the room in your home, giving it the desired amount of space you are looking......

Words: 4631 - Pages: 19


...Consumer rights and duties Consumerism, what is? Consumerism is the protection of the rights and interests of the general pool of buyers, or an obsession with buying material goods or items. Consumer Rights * Right to satisfaction of basic needs: The consumer has the right to goods and services to ensure their survival: adequate food, clothing, adequate housing, health care, education and sanitation. * The right to protection of health and physical safety: Life, health and consumer physical security can’t be compromised by the goods and services at our disposal. * Right to choose: Consumers should be able to choose products and services at competitive prices, with a satisfactory quality assurance. * Right to quality of goods and services: Goods and services must comply with quality requirements set by the law for each of them, fulfilling the purpose for which they are intended. * Right to training and education for consumption: The state should promote training activities, primarily integrated into school curricular and programs, creating consumer attitudes critical and selective. * Right to information for consumption: The supplier of goods and service are required to provide true and complete information to the consumer. In the case of goods and essential services, companies that operate on an exclusive basis has the obligation to inform in advance the consumer cuts or interruptions of supply, unless unforeseen cases. * Right to protection......

Words: 399 - Pages: 2

Directors Duties

...------------------------------------------------- business and company law Section 228(1) of the Companies Act 2014 details the eight fiduciary duties directors of companies are obliged and compelled by law to comply with. The question is why it is necessary through the application of law to limit director’s decision making responsibility. The potential for directors to abuse their positions of power with regards to company’s assets in the daily running of the company seems limitless even when directors are in their own perception acting bona fides with regards to their decisions. Section 228(1) is so important and appropriate to business law as Directors are persons who according to Callanan(2007,p207) ‘have been entrusted with powers for the benefit of others’ but the potential to damage one person or persons to benefit another is so highly possible that the law is compelled to control directors decisions. Section 228(1) (d) addresses a directors duties ‘to not use the company’s property, information or opportunities for his or her own or anyone else’s benefit’. The case of Regal Hastings v Gulliver (1942) is one which has involved much debate throughout the years. The directors of Regal although acting in their opinion bona fides, through holding a position as directors were privy to information that, had they not held their position as directors would not have been able to benefit from the transaction that they undertook. The key point behind this case was that......

Words: 2154 - Pages: 9

Moral Duty?

...Patricia Sanchez Philosophy 105 Intro to Ethics Question 2 of 2 Do we have a moral duty to help starving people on the other side of the world, who we will never meet? To aid hungry nations or not, is a complex issue. One that, I myself, have had some trouble even formulating an idea. Initially, when I think of this, I immediately say “Yes, we help!” But after reviewing some of the literature, case studies and political views on the subject, I am not so sure. As human beings, I believe that we have an inherent duty to help others who are in need. I prefer not to mention things I have done to help others, but in this context I believe it to be imperative. If someone is hungry, I have gone out of my way to feed them; the consequences are of no value to me, whether it was financial repercussions on my part or the part of an establishment, made no matter to me. If a person is hungry, you feed them. A family one time, had hit a deer on their way home to Flagstaff, I already had a full lodge and house with guests in town for a wedding; I called and asked my mother to oblige these people, who had a small child and baby. She refused, stating, “She couldn’t manage the extra stress right now.” I was appalled. Eventually a place was offered and the family was provided a place to sleep that night. However, my animosity towards my own Mother grew intensely. This scenario has been repeated over and over in my life. I truly believe that virtues are implanted in us, and......

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Duty of Care

...The topic that the writer will discuss in this paper is employer’s duty of care. The video that is attached to this assignment touched on the topic of employer’s duty of care and issues of compensation. Throughout this assignment the writer will convey to the audience the pros and cons of both men in the video, as well as go into detail on the topic of employer’s duty of care. 1. Explain whether Jake’s actions are in or out of “his scope of employment.” Jake's actions are out of his scope of employment. The reason being is because he is taking his time in completing the free oil changes. Based upon the writer’s observations it seemed as if Jake used the free oil changes as a means to get Herman's attention. Jake felt that he should be paid overtime regardless of the fact that he was a full time salary employee. Jake’s certification would have been jeopardized if he did not do the oil change properly. Jake stated that as a certified mechanic he has a “duty” to provide exceptional service and to ensure that each car is maintenance properly. 2. Explain whether or not Herman is responsible for Jake’s injury. Based upon the writer’s observation it’s safe to say that both parties are responsible for Jake’s injury. The reason the writer feels this is because Herman as a manager came up with the promotion to have free oil changes. Herman placed a high demand on his service team, and by doing so, he also took for granted the impact it would have on his personnel. Jake......

Words: 541 - Pages: 3

Seg of Duties

...Management, Planning and Organization of IS ISACA PROFESSIONAL RESOURCES SEGREGATION OF DUTIES WITHIN INFORMATION SYSTEMS This is an excerpt from the CISA Review Manual 2005 Chapter 2 - Management, Planning and Organization of IS CISA Review Manual 2005 - Pages 88-91 The entire publication and other exam study material can be purchased through the ISACA bookstore at www.isaca.org/cisabooks. CISA® REVIEW MANUAL SEGREGATION OF DUTIES DISCLAIMER ISACA has produced this publication as an educational resource to assist individuals preparing to take the CISA Certification Exam. It was produced independently from the CISA Certification Board, which has no input into or responsibility for its content. ISACA makes no claim that the Segregation of Duties Control Matrix is an industry standard. The material is solely intended as a general guideline to assist in identifying potential conflicts. Functions, designations, nature of business processes, technology deployed and risks may vary from one organization to another. In determining the proper controls, the IS auditing professional should apply his or her own professional judgment to the specific circumstances presented within an enterprise or information technology environment. CISA Review Manual 2005 1 Chapter 2 SEGREGATION OF DUTIES WITHIN IS Actual job titles and organizational structures may vary greatly from one organization to another, depending on the size and nature of the business. However, it is......

Words: 1893 - Pages: 8