Empathy Article

In: Business and Management

Submitted By joegeo86
Words 10116
Pages 41


Measurement of empathy in nursing research: systematic review
Juping Yu & Maggie Kirk
Accepted for publication 16 July 2008

Correspondence to M. Kirk: e-mail: mkirk@glam.ac.uk Juping Yu MSc PhD RN Research Fellow Faculty of Health, Sport and Science, University of Glamorgan, Wales, UK Maggie Kirk BSc PhD RN Head of Research/Leader Genomics Policy Unit and Lead Professional Specialist (Nursing Professions) NHS National Genetics Education and Development Centre Faculty of Health, Sport and Science, University of Glamorgan, Wales, UK

YU J. & KIRK M. (2008)

Measurement of empathy in nursing research: systematic review. Journal of Advanced Nursing 64(5), 440–454 doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2008.04831.x

Title. Measurement of empathy in nursing research: systematic review. Aim. This paper is a report of a systematic review to identify, critique and synthesize nursing studies of the measurement of empathy in nursing research. Background. The profound impact of empathy on quality nursing care has been recognized. Reported empathy levels among nurses range from low to welldeveloped and there is clearly debate about what constitutes empathy and how it can be measured and improved. Data sources. Searches were made of the CINAHL, MEDLINE and PsycINFO databases, using the terms ‘empathy’, ‘tool’, ‘scale’, ‘measure’, ‘nurse’, and ‘nursing’, singly or in combination to identify literature published in the English language between 1987 and 2007. Methods. A systematic review was carried out. The included papers were critically reviewed, relevant data were extracted, and a narrative synthesis was conducted. Results. Thirty papers representing 29 studies met the inclusion criteria. Three types of studies were identified: descriptive studies (n = 12), studies of empathy and patient outcomes (n = 6), and evaluational studies (n = 11). Twenty…...

Similar Documents

Empathy and Social Learning

...Running Head: EMPATHY AND SOCIAL LEARNING Developing Empathy: Nurturing Through Social Learning Abstract This paper explores the Social Learning Theory and how prosocial behavior, specifically empathy, is cultured through observation, modeling and imitation. Empathy is defined through a review of Bandura’s Bobo Doll experiment, Jeremy Sloan’s article on developing empathy and the impact it has on animals in our world, and an assessment of empathy in future criminal justice professionals. All provide evidence and data to support the finding that adults have lasting influence on children and how ones behavior is formed. Empathy is a vital trait and it’s a primary requisite for successfully managing daily experiences. Key words: Empathy, Modeling, Social Learning, and Development Introduction The development of empathy allows us the innate ability to relate to another’s experiences, motives and feelings. It is the foundation of compassion and caring, and is monumental in many of life’s challenges and successes. It is what allows us to learn from others and become responsible, caring adults. Many significant professions require empathy: medical care, fire rescue, education, criminal justice, and most importantly parenting. Tragic events such as slavery and the Holocaust illuminate the significance of empathy, it’s part in humankind’s wellbeing, and how requisite it is to encourage healthy development of the trait (Sajo, 2011). It is therefore of......

Words: 2089 - Pages: 9

Art and Empathy

...memoirs Maus by Art Spiegelman are examples of how men suffered during the Holocaust and the amount of empathy produced from the suffering of these men. Empathy is the ability to see something from somebody else's point of view and to walk a mile in their shoes if you will. Men are very prideful individuals who are very dominating members of society. The atrocity of the Holocaust has been displayed and expressed through various pieces of art and literature. Famous Holocaust painters like Felix Nussbaum have expressed this atrocity through art. Felix Nussbaum was a prisoner at Auschwitz who died there in 1944. The image to the right is one Nussbaum’s paintings that survived the Holocaust. Besides the man sitting on this wooden box, you see two other men in the rear who appear to be using the bathroom. The condition that these men were forced to live in horse stable like conditions. These men were treated like animals and the lowest level of the food chain. Maybe this was a photo he painted of himself. Felix Nussbaum wanted people to know the horrible atrocities they went through. He wanted to show how men were living. His painting produces a great deal of empathy because no one could imagine having to wipe his or her feces with straw. The men in the background could have been former bankers, jewelers, or a father. Now, he is just a number in society. There is a lot of empathy produced from this photo because no one could fathom having to wipe his or her waste up with grass......

Words: 1545 - Pages: 7

The Importance of Empathy in the Workplace

...Even the best nurses, however, can learn tools for improving their empathy. In fact, most people who score high on assessments in the area of empathy often have no idea what they do; they just know that they like people, they enjoy working with and helping people, and they value people as individuals. In a recent presentation to healthcare professionals on empathy in New York City, the audience concurred that healthcare professionals do exhibit empathy most of the time - to their patients. When asked about the use of empathy with colleagues or with family or even with themselves, the audience seemed pretty certain they could do a better job. What is Empathy? Empathy is the ability to put oneself in the shoes of another person. The positive psychology definition is: The quality of feeling and understanding another person's situation in the present moment -- their perspectives, emotions, actions (reactions) -- and communicating this to the person. So you know what they are feeling, or at least you suspect you know what they are experiencing, and you communicate that to elicit further discussion or clarification. Empathy is an Emotional Intelligence (EI) competency. In the field of Emotional Intelligence, there are four clusters of competencies and eighteen competencies. The four clusters are: - Self-Awareness - Self-Management - Social Awareness - Relationship Management Empathy falls under Social Awareness. This skill reflects a person's ability to connect......

Words: 668 - Pages: 3


...Empathy is not the same as sympathy. Empathy is a way to experience an emotionally or painful situation together, helping the client to feel less alone and understood. Sympathy is a feeling sorry for a person or client’s situation. Empathy can help a person move beyond feelings of negativity and hopelessness about a situation so that they can start to focus on moving through the situation. Even though empathy can lead to too much self-disclosure, it is crucial for nurses to apply empathy towards fearful cancer patients because a better therapeutic relationship is created and the patients feel more at ease. Literature Review Arnold and Boggs define empathy as the ability to be sensitive to and communicate understanding of the client’s feelings (2011). Empathy is to understand what it is like to “walk in someone else’s shoes” or to know what it is like to understand how that person feels by going through a similar experience (Kirk, 2007). Brunero, Lamont and Coates states that empathy is the ability to understand the meaning and feelings of a person and communicate those feelings back to that person (2010). Empathy is a relationship that allows open and honest discussion about one’s feelings (Haraldsdottir, 2007). A nurse is able to show empathy by a number of ways. You can display empathy by explaining a medical procedure or test in non-medical terms so the client can understand and feel in control of...

Words: 2035 - Pages: 9

The Application of Empathy to Professions in Psychology

...The Application of Empathy to Professions in Psychology The following report discusses the importance of communicating effectively within a health-related context – more specifically, in a psychological environment – and will critically explore the effective application of empathy as a key communication skill utilised in the practice of a professional psychologist. Particular emphasis will be placed upon the relevance of empathy across a broad range of clientele, the ways in which empathy is communicated effectively to clients, its purpose in the context of client-practitioner trust, factors which may inhibit the conveyance of empathy, and the influence empathy plays in day-to-day social interactions, which will be examined through a personal account. Within the role of a practising psychologist, and indeed across all areas of health professions which incorporate the need for interpersonal communication, empathy is an invaluable skill which helps the practitioner to garner an understanding of their client’s emotions and thoughts, and is essential to a successful clinical environment (Gerdes, Segal, Jackson, & Mullins, 2011). Unlike sympathy, empathy does not necessarily require the acceptance of an individual’s behaviour in order to grasp and empathise with the feelings they may be experiencing; rather, it requires the process of emotionally engaging with the client in an unbiased attempt to understand their thoughts and emotions, and in order to do so, a......

Words: 2197 - Pages: 9

Cognitive Empathy

...social reasoning from narrative characters tested the effects of interactivity on cognitive empathy. The study took place in three fourth grade classrooms, using convenience sampling and cluster assignment. The study compared print and hypertext versions of two illustrated stories using between-subjects, posttest-only control group design. Perspective taking and fantasy identification were measured through questionnaires, and two intrapersonal empathy outcomes were measured through writing prompts. Interactivity was found to negatively affect fantasy identification and intrapersonal empathy. Thus for a reader positioned outside of a story, perceived agency may reduce identification with characters and therefore reduce their effectiveness as social models. These findings may inform the design of media to support observational learning of social reasoning. The purpose of the study was to examine the association between affective empathy, cognitive empathy, and gender on cyber bullying among adolescents. Participants were 396 adolescents from Singapore with age ranging from 12 to 18 years. Adolescents responded to a survey with scales measuring both affective and cognitive empathy, and cyber bullying behavior. A three-step hierarchical multiple regression analysis was used with cyber bullying scores as the dependent variable. Gender was dummy coded and both affective and cognitive empathy were centered using the sample mean prior to creating interaction terms and entering them......

Words: 375 - Pages: 2

Empathy and the Platinum Rule

...The Platinum Rule Delvin KWA A0072584Y Everyone knows the Golden Rule: “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” This sounds like a sound starting point for an ethical approach. So sound that it has earned itself its golden title. Many philosophies and religions worldwide incorporate this rule, and it is not without surprise. The Golden Rule might not be all-encompassing, and hence its negative form, the Silver Rule, which states: “Do not do unto others as you would not have them do unto you”, was born for complementarity. Together, these rules are based upon the importance of empathy and this ethic of reciprocity has been what many different cultures have resolved conflicts with. However, the Golden Rule is no panacea. Think about it: “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” This is based upon the assumption that other people would like to be treated the same way that you would like to be treated. And we know instinctively that this cannot always be true, because everyone is different and has differing tastes and preferences. So now what? Could there be another rule that might tie up the loose ends? Enter the Platinum Rule: “Do unto everyone as they would have you do unto them.” This rule obliges us to respect and consider the needs and wants of people, and then act based on this understanding. It is what prevails in gift-giving, in earnest advice-giving, and so on. The focus of the relationship shifts from “this is what I want, so I'll give......

Words: 1976 - Pages: 8


...Do you listen and respond in ways that a significant person in your life would perceive as empathic? I would define empathy by the words of Rogers (1975), one of the most influential American psychologists in the exploration of empathy, that it means” entering the private perceptual world of the other and becoming thoroughly at home in it” (“Empathic: An Unappreciated Way of Being,” para. 17). In my mind, in this short definition there is everything what empathy consists of. To be attentive and delicate without making judgments or expectations, to be respectful and willing to center other person’s feelings and emotions, and to put aside our own needs and concerns for a while. The listener lets the speaker know, "I understand your problem and how you are feeling about it and I am interested in what you are saying and I am not judging you." When dealing with a person who is feeling troubled empathic listening and supporting response become the most important and powerful strategies to apply. As Adler, Rodman and Sevigny (2011) say that ” in empathic listening… the goal is to build a relationship or help the speaker solve a problem… to become better acquainted with others and show them that their opinions and feelings matter to you” (p. 152). From my point of view, neither advising response nor judging response is appropriate in such sort of situations. Furthermore, they more likely make the situation worse and make a person to feel......

Words: 1263 - Pages: 6


...What empathy means to me is when we are making an attempt to understand another person feeling from their perspective. When you are trying to see and understand how they are feeling from their point of view. An example that I can use is a current situation that I am having with my son dad, I met him when I was a sophomore in high school and he was a junior. I was the less fortunate child with many home issues and he was a more fortunate person. Had no other siblings but had his own car, well-kept and athlete. We grew up completely different and was afforded different opportunities. We eventually took different routes and well mine went in a more positive direction and he ended up being kicked out of the military and doing a few stints in prison for drugs and other violations. He now loves back home with his mother is a no where job barely making ends meet and just a lot of issues. I on the other hand am the complete opposite. I’m doing well, my own home, cars, family etc. Its hard for me to empathize with him because he was given this opportunity but chose to take the wrong path and do illegal things. I don’t feel sorry for people who screw themselves out of a good opportunity. I would not do anything different than I am doing now, he is an adult and he made those decisions knowing he has responsibility. I a firm believer is not raising an adult. When meeting someone for the first time in a common friendship I’m looking for someone that has similar interest that I do.......

Words: 485 - Pages: 2

Empathy of Design

...I chose the Mammen 2008 article because it talks about food insecurity and how it relates to poverty. Food insecurity is a big persisting problem among the impoverished and I want to learn how it directly relates to poverty. One of the most interesting points that the author points out in the article is the fact that the US is one of the richest nations in the world based on its per capita GDP, but when compared to other developed nations, there are many prevalent paradoxes that emerge from the US. The US has lower levels of life expectancy and higher rates of infant mortality and child poverty than other developed countries. The main concern as the author points out, is that the US spends less time trying to help families out of poverty and instead is growing more and more in class inequality. This article, based on research, shows that low-income families in the US are more susceptible to food insecurity than any other demographic. But there is also another paradox where rural low-income families are more food insecure in prosperous states compared to those in less prosperous states. From this conclusion, it seems clear to me that food insecurity doesn’t relate to where someone is located in the nation. Rather, low income is the most determining factor to food insecurity and this makes a lot of sense because access to food and produce isn’t hard to find anywhere in the country. It comes down to if one can afford to eat. The point of this article is to find the......

Words: 419 - Pages: 2

Empathy-Altruism Hypothesis

...Empathy-altruism hypothesis Empathy-altruism hypothesis is a prosocial behavior that states people are motivated to act in an altruism manner by the empathy they feel for others. Altruism is defined as a true desire to help those in need and expect nothing in return, not even satisfaction. Empathy is defined as a feeling of understanding the experience that another being is facing. Empathy-altruism hypothesis has a very important significance to American culture as well as cultures around the world because we all should strive towards altruism motivation to ensure our own survival in the future. Empathy has different elements and different levels dependent upon the situation and feelings felt by the observer. If the observer has empathy towards the observed, and not only feel what they are experiencing, but understand what they are experiencing then the observer is experiencing the two elements of empathy. A person with a high level of empathy would be an example of the empathy-altruism hypothesis. A person with a low level of empathy would be considered selfish. “Empathy is a vicarious emotional experience in which you feel and understand what another person feels.” (Bell) Empathy is a natural feeling that most people experience, it is if they choose to embrace this feeling and act upon it that determines their individual level and whether it will trigger altruism motivation. Altruism is a desire to help other people without a sense of obligation and to expect......

Words: 593 - Pages: 3

Empathy of Animals

...Study of Attitude, Empathy, and Human Uniqueness of Emotion in Animals Abstract This correlational study was conducted to determine and explore the relationships between empathy, attitudes towards animals, and beliefs about human uniqueness of emotion. This was a quasi- experimental because we studied man versus women and also pet owners versus non-pet owners. We expected to find a positive correlation between the empathy and AAS score. While also exploring the relationships between the HUES and empathy or AAS score. We predicted that women would have higher empathy and AAS scores than men as well as pet owners having higher AAS scores than non- pet owners. This study was conducted in New York, where 60 voluntary participants completed surveys. The results of the study illustrated and provided a statistically significant positive correlation between scores on the E-Scale and the AAS and a significant negative correlation between scores on the E-Scale and HUES and well as between the AAS and the HUES. There was also a significant gender difference in AAS scores with women having more positive attitudes toward animals compared to men. However, there was no significant gender difference in HUES scores. Similarly, there were significant effects of pet ownership on both E-Scale scores and on AAS scores. Specifically, pet owners had higher levels of empathy and also had more positive attitudes toward animals compared to non-pet owners. There was no significant effect of pet......

Words: 2361 - Pages: 10

Empathy in Counselling

...EMPATHY Empathy is the ability to recognize and relate to other people’s emotions and thoughts. Empathic thinking is often characterized as the willingness and ability to place oneself in another person’s situation, to feel another person’s feelings, or to recognize that another person might experience feelings in the same way as oneself. When we feel sympathy for someone we might view them with pity. While pity makes a victim of the sufferer, empathy empowers them: "i have a sense of your world, you are not alone, and we will go through this together". Carl Rogers(1969), the founder of person centered counseling, concluded that the important elements of empathy are: • The therapist understands the client's feelings • The therapist's responses reflects the client's mood and the content of what has been said • The therapist' tone of voice conveys the ability to share the client's feelings. 1.1 Role of Empathy in Therapy Empathy is considered essential to therapy because for any therapeutic tactic to work, the therapist has to make the person in treatment feel understood. To do this, the therapist must not only understand what a person says in a therapy session but also understand what the person is not saying and communicate this understanding. Therapists who are highly empathic can help people in treatment face past experiences and obtain a greater understanding of both the experience and feelings surrounding it. Empathy is different from sympathy, which can......

Words: 846 - Pages: 4

Empathy Exercise

...A first impression always sticks in our minds; at the same time we can not necessarily control it. Snap judgments can be made due to our upbringing, from our parents, siblings, grandparents. Their likes, dislikes, beliefs can influence our empathy level. This being said; I have negative feelings towards a friend of my boyfriend, her name is Amanda. My first impression of Amanda was she seemed okay, than she started talking. Always complained about her boyfriend, and how she said that he was doing drugs, and this and that, but she doesn’t do drugs. The problem with this was every time she came around, she looked strung out on something, and she would just sit there and drink, and drink! She would talk about how she would do anything to get her son back, and that it wasn’t her fault that his father got custody of him. She is always talking about doing whatever it takes to get her son back, but she has not done anything. Amanda would say that she never drank in front of her son, never smoked in front of him; when in fact she did and still does. During one of her visits, my boyfriend and I were there, she was smoking, pouring beer into a cup and drinking it. While these things are not frowned upon, it was just shocking to see how easily she dismissed everything she said previously. There are other situations that have since then just plain out bugged me. She easily points the finger at her, now ex-boyfriend, and how he was such a drug head, but she has been straight for a......

Words: 459 - Pages: 2

Association Between Personality and Empathy

...Association between Personality and Empathy The ability to empathise is an important factor in day to day interactions and influences the development of moral reasoning and an effective control of aggression (del Barrio, Aluja, Garcia, 2004) although Penner, Fritzsche, Craiger and Freifield (1995) argues that although prosocial behaviour is usually linked with empathy, the findings insist that it is instead situational. Personality trait ratings and the ability to interpret facial expressions are conducted through questionnaires such as Goldberg’s Unipolar Big-Five Markers to map out personality attributes (Thompson 2008) and Baron-Cohen’s Reading the Mind in the Eyes test (Baron-Cohen, Wheelwright, Hill, Raste and Plumb, 2001). The basic traits of neuroticism, extraversion, openness, agreeableness, and conscientiousness also known as the Five Factor model are closely linked to an individual’s disposition (Hartmann, Heidesgades, 2006) and through a study on 832 Spanish adolescents using both the Spanish versions of Bryant’s Empathy Index for Children and Adolescents and the Big Five Questionnaire, del Barrio et all (2004) reported that there was a strong correlation between positive traits such as agreeableness and empathy for both boys and girls. Based on previous meta-analytic research that suggest female have a higher aptitude in decoding non-verbal information (Hall, Hutton and Morgan, 2010), Hall states that women indeed have a higher accuracy on facial......

Words: 555 - Pages: 3