Ethical Dilemma Assignment

In: Business and Management

Submitted By kianhashempour
Words 1766
Pages 8
Thank you for being willing to take part in this interview exploring ethical conflict or turbulence. I would like to transcribe the content of this interview to form a written document to be submitted to Sheffield Hallam University as a piece of assessed piece of coursework. It is important that you only take part in this interview if you want to. As such I would be delighted if you would complete and sign this confidentiality questionnaire prior to the interview taking place.

(i) In general terms are you willing to take part in this interview: and an edited transcript of the interview submitted to Sheffield Hallam?
(ii) Are you happy for your own name to be used in the transcript: or do you want the final transcript to written up with a pseudonym?
Own name
(iii) Are you happy for the names of other people and organisations to be used in the final transcript: or do you want all other names to be content of this transcription to be submitted to Sheffield Hallam?
(iv) Are you happy for me to submit the final transcript without you reviewing it - or do you want to reserve the right to see the final transcript before I submit?
Submit unseen
(v) Sometimes the ethical dilemmas described in these transcripts provide real life case studies that can be helpful to show other students, and can provide rich data for research projects. Would you be willing for this transcript to be used in further teaching or research - or would you prefer the transcript to be solely used in the submission of an assessed piece of coursework? Limit to coursework submission
Signed: Kian Hashempour.
Date: 21/01/2013

Your help, and wisdom, is much valued. Any queries should be directed to

Ethical Dilemma Assignment: The Interview
Kian: Hello there.
Sami: Hi.
Kian: Um, you alright?
Sami: awesome, you?

Similar Documents

Ethical Dilemmas

...Abstract According to the phase 2 individual project assignment instructions, each student is asked to look at two scenarios and answer the related ethical questions following each one (CTU Online, 2013). Additionally, it is asked that each student provide a discussion on the new GAAP guidelines for consolidating entities, and to provide an example of a firm that has experienced trouble for failure to comply with the GAAP guidelines. Ethical Dilemmas in Partnerships Scenario 1: In the first scenario, there are two partners in an antique business, Mr. Right and Mr. Wrong. Mr. Right manages the store, and Mr. Wrong travels and purchases antiques to add to their store inventory. The each may borrow items from the inventory on occasion for one reason or another. While Mr. Right was out of town Mr Wrong’s daughter was married and had a desire for one of the inventory items valued at $5,000. So Mr. Wrong took the item from inventory and gave it to his daughter as a wedding gift. He recorded the item as a debit from the COGS for $5,000. The question is asked what are the ethical aspects of Mr. Wrong’s actions and how should he have recorded the transaction? To begin with, they are both wrong for allowing the other to take unpaid for inventory items from the store. It should be made clear in the partnership agreement that any inventory product removed from the store for any......

Words: 1368 - Pages: 6

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma Coursework Assignment James: Where did you work? Simon: Cadeby quarry, run by Lafarge Aggregates. James: What was your role there? Simon: I was the supervisor. James: Did you ever face an ethical dilemma whilst you were working at the quarry? Simon: Erm... What exactly do you mean? James: Well its a situation where a clear sense of right and wrong has become a difficult choice due to the situation you are in. Simon: Just give me a minute to think. James: Take your time, just start whenever you have one. Simon: Well when I was at the quarry we used to have scrap laying around for quite a while that belonged to other companies. One day I noticed that a large pile of scrap steel that had been lying around for a while was not there any more. I thought this was strange as no one was supposed to be coming to pick it up. James: Was it normal for scrap to be lying around for long periods and then going overnight? Simon: No, but I asked everyone around in the quarry and no one seemed to know anything, so I carried on as normal. But on my way to the car park the next day there was a piece of paper lying on the floor. I figured that I must have dropped it myself but when I opened it up it was a receipt from a scrap metal dealers worth a couple of hundred pounds. James: Wow, I’m guessing its not normal to find those around? Simon: No, it was signed by my boss who I then suspected to have stolen the scrap James: Were you a hundred percent sure? Or was......

Words: 476 - Pages: 2

Ethical Dilemma

...An Ethical Dilemma (Chapter 6) Lael Mathews has to decide between three different people to promote to manager. One is a thirty-four year old African American female, one is a fifty-seven year old Caucasian man, and the third one is a twenty-seven year old Asian American. They all have three different situations and problems of their own. Lael Mathews know each ones background which makes it even harder to make a decision as to which one deserves and will best fit the position. Liz is the thirty four year old African American who is divorced, has one child, been in the company four years, has a high energy level, and graduated in the lower half of her college class. Roy is the fifty seven year old Caucasian who is married, has three children, been with the company twenty years, energy level is average to low, and graduated in the top half of his class. And lastly Quang is the twenty-seven year old Asian American who is single, no kids, been with the company three years, works sixty hours a week, and graduated top three percent of her class. Advantages and Disadvantages of each Candidate Liz only really has maybe two advantages and that would be that if she was chosen she would be the first African American female to manager at that level and she has a high energy level meaning she is willing to put forth the effort. Now her disadvantages would be her academic credentials, her job experience, and the fact that her child has had many medical issues that could......

Words: 810 - Pages: 4

Ethical Dilemma

...Assignment 4 – The Ethical Dilemma M. Markham BBA400 Advanced Global Management Professor Charles Main, MBA, MAIB March 22, 2014 Assignment 4 – The Ethical Dilemma Identify the problem. The problem or concern is two-fold, whether or not it is ethical to hire models to work the company booth as well as whether or not it is ethical if said model is to wear revealing clothing. This is an ethical concern as it can be seen as employee discrimination as the “looks” of the women is what qualifies them for the position. It is also a question of exploiting women as they are to be models dressed specifically to draw attention to the company booth. Examine the facts. The first relevant fact is that the company is an American company operating abroad. This means that they are still governed by U.S labor laws but also must abide by the Russian laws that apply as well. Another question would be whether or not the proposed “model” would be a Russian women employed from the local resources, or an American citizen. This is an important fact as the federal discrimination statutes have limited extraterritorial application. “Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits discrimination in employment based on race, color, religion, sex or national origin, previously stated that “Aliens working for U.S. companies abroad are not covered by the Act...But, U.S. citizens working abroad are protected,” however, “this was amended in 1991 to include a ‘foreign laws......

Words: 909 - Pages: 4

Ethical Dilemma

...obtaining such information the marketing manager, in charge of the Silicon 6 project, proposed to double the original fee agreed upon. The marketing manager also stated that he had 10 more equally lucrative projects like the current one. Problems faced by Martha McCaskey Martha McCaskey had serious doubts as to both the propriety of asking for such information and Phil Devon’s motivation in so eagerly offering to help her. McCaskey had two options. With the additional funding available from the client, she could have Phil Devon provide analysis of several alternatives for manufacturing state of the art chips, including the one used at the competitor’s Silicon 6 plant, such as to avoid suspicion. The second option was to hand over the assignment to Chuck Kaufmann, a senior associate, who handled many of the division’s projects which required obtaining information that a competitor would deem as proprietary. Regardless as to the decision, Martha McCaskey felt, that no matter which option she chose, completing the Silicon 6 project would compromise her values. Evidence of this can be seen when she states ‘this is a guy who’s trying to do good in the world. How can I be doing this? I have an EE degree from CalTech, an MBA from Harvard, and here I am trying to sleaze this guy’. McCaskey had wondered ‘where do you draw the line on proprietary information?’ McCaskey questioned if she was about to engage in a ‘gentleman’s industrial espionage?’ Until the present task she had......

Words: 2834 - Pages: 12

Ethical Dilemma

...was pretty sure she was a pseudo seizure patient. When it came to looking at what drugs she could be given, the only drug she was not allergic to was Morphine. When doing assessments on the patient, she would always say that her pain was an 8-9 before pain medication and a 7/10 after pain medication. Every 4 hours the patient would put her call light on and complain of pain. However, the patient showed no signs of pain as she was doing her hair and putting on makeup to look good for her boyfriend who was coming to see her soon. With the patient requesting pain medications frequently, showing no apparent signs of pain or seizure activity and allergic to every type of medication makes me suspicious of the patient drug seeking. So the ethical dilemma is should the patient be given pain medication when they requests it every 4 hrs, when not appearing to be in pain? The three options that I was alternating between were medicating the patient as ordered when they request it, give the patient half the dose ordered when they request it, or delay the patient’s dose to every 6 hours or not give it at all. The moral principles involved are autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence and accountability. Medicating the patient when they request it would be upholding to the principle of autonomy. Beneficence is an action done for the benefit of the patient. Administering pain medication upon request may be promoting good for the patient, as we want the patient to be pain free, which in......

Words: 1086 - Pages: 5

Ethical Dilemma

...COURSE: MGT 6950, STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT OF BUSINESS POLICY STUDENT ID: RG8520 DUE DATE: 03 APRIL 2011 INSTRUCTOR: DR. DONALD L. GUSFA ASSIGNMENT DESCRIPTION: CHAPTER NO 4&5 TOTAL NO. OF PAGES: 3 Overview – Everyone does it Jim Willis was the Vice President of marketing and sales for International Satellite Images(ISI), an aerospace company pioneers in the high resolution space cameras. The ISI team had been preparing a proposal for a Japanese government contractor for a commitment of a minimum imagery purchase for five years. But in a recent meeting, it had been revealed that a technical snag might delay the launch of satellite for a minimum of one year. Fred Bellard, the President of ISI, told Jim not to change the already published official date of launch, though Jim protested the use of incorrect date as it was clearly unethical. Fred’s rationale was that disclosure would have a negative effect on contract negotiations and might result in severe financial repercussions and suggested that it is a standard industry practice to withhold negative information. Jim believed that not disclosing the information might be unethical and affect his own reputation, and was wondering what to do. And also he was concerned that if a new launch was announced, it would delay signing a contract with the Japanese customer. Since the construction and ongoing operation of each programmes were financed by venture......

Words: 632 - Pages: 3

An Ethical Dilemma

...Case Study: An Ethical Dilemma Name Institution Case Study: An Ethical Dilemma Question 1 Dr. Vaji would like to meet with Leo in order to discuss ways in which adolescent clients may be retained. Also, he wants to help him improve his treatment skills. Unfortunately, he does not know how much the information he was provided with by the other graduate students might influence their conversation and final supervisory report. As a result, he finds himself in an ethical dilemma because he is concerned on how to grade the student from his earlier reports or should he take into account the information he has just received from the other students. Apparently, he was not convinced enough by Leo Watson’s thought paper, so he advised him to incorporate more of the findings on ethnic discrimination into his papers and provide more complex perspectives. In other words, Watson was to provide more information from viewing the world through another person’s eyes. As a result, he might have taken the idea far enough to start behaving in the same manner he had described the ethnic minority would, which was prone to violence. On the other hand, Leo Watson as a person might possess the attributes described to Dr. Vaji by the other students as derogatory, harassing, and insulting to other ethnic groups. Seemingly, the nature of this dilemma has been framed by some APA Ethical principles. First, integrity plays a part simply because it demands honesty, accuracy, and truthfulness from......

Words: 1466 - Pages: 6

Ethical Dilemma

...MANAGER’S ETHICAL DILEMMA -- # 1 1、Ethical Dilemma The primary problem is whether Sally Cook should accept Bossey’s offer to get higher value for her stock. Then the question is what Cook should do? 2、Stakeholders ① Ralph Bossey: He has the right to use the way of takeover to make money, even if it will cause harmful effect on employees in that company and development of community health. ② Stockholders (like Sally Cook): They have the right to choose to accept the attractive offer from Bossey or not. ③ Employees: They have the right to guarantee a stable job in the company. 3、 Alternative Actions and Consequences. ① Accept the offer from Bossey. If Cook accepted the offer, she can get double current market value for her holdings. But it will cause lay off many employees in Graham Corporation. It can also restrain company’s nutritional improvements and product innovation. Finally, it will influence the development of community health. ② Not accept the offer. If Cook does not accept the offer, it will benefit many employees and community health. But she has to extend the working time to gain a better life to eliminate her financial worry. 4、 Analysis From my opinion, I think Cook should not accept the offer from Bossey. The following reasons are the factors that Cook should consider before she makes final decision. From a legal point of view, what Bossey does is legal. The way he uses to take over the company is also legal, but his action will have negative effect...

Words: 654 - Pages: 3

Ethical Dilemmas

...Ethical Dilemmas Kevin Brock April 26, 2015 CWV 101: Christian Worldview Instructor: Peter Rasor People from all walks of life face many ethical dilemmas. These dilemmas have consequences. Our worldview determines how we deal with these dilemmas, and guides us to the right decisions. In this essay, I will examine an ethical issues through my Christian worldview. I will also present other viewpoints, and compare them to mine. Ethical Dilemma This dilemma involves my friend Paul. Paul has been working very hard in practice, and the weight room and has earned a starting position on his team. The team has recently been winning more, and many of the players are using a new performance enhancing drug. Paul’s teammates are always reminding him that it is not a banned substance, and the coach has turned a blind eye to the whole issue. Paul told me that his coach is making some changes, and he may lose his starting position. He is starting to think about actually taking this drug so he does not lose his spot. The dilemma is that Paul could just take the drug, and get to keep his position as a starter. Since the drug is not listed as banned, and the coach ignores its use, it should a good choice. No one will ever know. There are a few things that could be done to resolve this dilemma: * I could tell Paul to stand his ground, and not take the drug. He could let his talent stand on its own. I would tell him that taking the drugs could be dangerous, and its simply wrong...

Words: 1311 - Pages: 6

Ethical Dilemma

...notify the professor about K.C’s behavior and attitude towards the group assignment he wouldn’t have to worry about failing the assignment or being in trouble for plagiarism which wasn’t his fault. By protecting himself from being caught, he is able to make sure that K.C get a grade deserves and not one that he didn’t work for. • K.C- the main stakeholder would be K.C because TJ decision could cost him either his grade for the class and record in the business school or more work because he could be forced by the group to do more work on the assignment. In K.C’s interest he would rather that the group just hand in the assignment as is because of his minimal effort attitude. • Professor- The professor is in charge of the class and would want T.J to inform him about his partner K.C would is not doing his share of the work correctly. The professor wants to ensure that fair grades are earned by students and wouldn’t want to just hand out grades to those who did not earn them. • Group members- Question # 2 T.J is facing a dilemma with his group member K.C because he would rather be ethical and not hand in plagiarized work which if caught by the marker would end up costing him his grade as well. Though the part of the assignment that is plagiarized is completed by K.C there is a good chance the professor would punish the whole group because the group also should have been checking each other’s parts. The dilemma that T.J faces is that if he tells the professor about the......

Words: 621 - Pages: 3

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma (Author’s name) (Institutional Affiliation) Abstract This research paper seeks to resolve a particular case of an ethical dilemma. This has been necessitated by the fact that ethical dilemmas are a recurrent part of life. Moreover, ethical dilemmas have become a key point of argument in the field of ethics and interestingly, philosophy as well (Garsten & Hernes, 2009). As an inividual, I find myself facing moral dilemma situation quite frequently which makes the exploration of this subject a fascinating intrigue. This exhaustive research thus attempts to integrate all the possible actions that can be undertaken to lead towards the understanding of ethical dilemma. Methodologies used to accomplish this include the three stage ethical dilemma solving process that duly applies two main approaches. These approaches are consequentialist and deontological which have been widely applied to give step by step details on how to handle the given ethical dilemma. The article dissects on subsequent decision making after thorough strive to balance between what is morally acceptable within a person’s surroundings and self interests entrenched in a human being. A thorough discussion on the particular viewpoints of ethical dilemma has unearthed the common result of individuals getting torn between self morals and societal expectations.. Finally, the research concludes that there is a need to evaluate decisions based on viewpoints......

Words: 1725 - Pages: 7

Ethical Dilemma

...Ethical Dilemma Lawrence Edwards ETH 316 August 15, 2012 Charles Parker Ethical Dilemma The ethical issues addressed are the violation of company policies and the implementation of new security procedures to prevent further issues within the organization. Aaron Webb and employee for the company, violated company laws by posting potentially damaging information about the company online. He was caught doing it by another employee who suspected him by using the company computers to hack into his personal computer to catch him in the act, also violating company laws by violating employee privacy. Both employees have broken company policy and both should be punished. But before you take disciplinary action you have to make sure your decisions benefit the company as a whole. Whether someone is fired or not it still affects everyone. In the assignment it discusses “stakeholders”, which are people who are the closet to the problem being affected the most. Some of the steps used to address this issue is to first investigate the problem. You also have to consider would it be fair to punish Aaron Webb for his actions even though his rights were violated in obtaining the proof that he was in fact the one posting the comments about the company. Another issue was with the new security measures put in place it required employees to carry ID badges identifying themselves and granting them access to certain facilities. A female Muslim employee brought up the issue that she can’t......

Words: 677 - Pages: 3

An Ethical Dilemma

...| An Ethical Dilemma | | Mary Ryan 8/27/2012 | Ethical dilemmas come up often within the workplace and can be difficult to handle when an employee needs to choose between what’s right and what’s wrong based on their own morals and principals. Handling ethical issues should be pursued in a steady and cautious approach towards matters that can potentially be dangerous or illegal. (Mayhew) One ethical dilemma that I was caught in the middle of left me in a position where I was almost forced into firing a person because of their sexual orientation. I felt this was an unethical request, and really made me think twice about the company I was working for and representing. A few years ago I worked for a company as a home manager. I was in the process of hiring some people to staff my home and when I picked all the candidates I went over all of them with the owner, who was also my boss. I ended up hiring in about five people and only one lasted. Sally, the lady that I had hired was an outstanding worker. She would come in early or stay late if I needed her to. She had no problems with switching her days around if another worker had something going on. Sally worked great with the clients and the clients loved working with her. She learned the job very quickly and was just an awesome employee. A few months after she had been working there, we had a huge crisis happen at the home. I was out of town with another manager working on opening up another group home and......

Words: 1270 - Pages: 6

Ethical Dilemma

...By definition, an ethical dilemma is a situation that will often involve an apparent conflict between moral imperatives, in which to obey one would result in transgressing another. When one combines this definition with the many problems employees and management face on a daily basis, you are bound to have plenty of examples for many different kinds of businesses, regardless of what the business is or the line of work. This internal conflict that people experience can cause many issues in today’s workplace, and in the next few paragraphs I will explain how, why, and produce some examples. One of the most popular examples of an ethical dilemma is the story of the man whose family is starving and he steals a loaf of bread for his family’s survival. At its core, this example covers all the bases: conflicting imperatives with regards to a need for food and breaking the law by stealing the food. There can be arguments made on both sides with no clear decision on what the right thing to do would be. When translated into today’s work environment, employed persons have conflicting thoughts and feelings every day because they face problems at work but also in their personal lives as well. Anytime one has two completely different sets of problems their chances for an ethical dilemma will rise. According to Puja Lalwani, who writes articles for, “A lot of people believe that there is no room for ethics in the workplace. In a world of fierce competition where everyone...

Words: 1751 - Pages: 8