Promote from Within and Hiring Form Outside

In: Business and Management

Submitted By wloon
Words 2290
Pages 10
Table of Contents Introduction 2 Question 1 3 Question 2 5 Advantages of promoting from within 5 Disadvantages of promoting from within 6 Advantages of bringing in from outside 7 Disadvantages of bringing in from outside 8 Impact of promoting from within on the morale of employees 9 Impact of bringing in outside on the morale of employees 10 Referencing 11

In my opinion based on the case study, it is not justified in appointing Mike Ullman, an outsider as CEO instead of Jessica Robert, who was instrumental in turning around the company between 2005 and 2010. The reason I disagree is because promoting from within brings a lot of benefits to employees and organization. I individually support promoting from within and I think that promoting from within is definitely more justified than bringing in an outsider. Research shows that insider and outsider both has different benefits and loss and it is depends on the managerial decision. Different management has different view towards insider and outsider. I have choose to support promoting from within in this assessment is because that the research make me believe that promoting from within can increase productivity and employees satisfaction. I have provides three strong reason to support my personal view.

Question 1
The first reason of promoting from within is good for morale. When the top management is decided to promote from within, the others employees are often very pleased because they think that “one of their own” has been promoted to a management-level position and makes them feel nothing is impossible. (David G. Javitch., 2005) The morale of employees will improve when they realize that every one of them is possible to be promoted and this usually leads to increase motivation of employees. Since Jessica Robert was instrumental in turning around the company, the others…...

Similar Documents


...Hiring internally is beneficial for both the company and employee. When companys recruit from within, they offer opportunity for advancement and promotion. This technique keeps employees motivated to work hard and as a result, One decreases. Due process policies sense that job security is high, which keeps employees to stay with an organization long-term. Also, companies benefit from internal recruitment by saving money. Recruiting externally costs the company money to train someone new, while the organization can reduce the cost by training someone internally slowly. There are certain business strategies that are best supported by recruiting externally. Firstly, certain entry-level or even upper-level positions may not be filled internally since there is no one available to fill those positions. Furthermore, outsiders can bring new ideas or new ways of doing business that can help the organization. Lastly, bringing in new talent from outside sources can help strenghten an organization and weaken the competitors. On the other hand, there are several strategies that might call for internal recruitment. It is to a companys advantage to hire someone withing who is already well known. The company knows how they work, what they are able to produce, and what they can expect from them. Second, internal employees are well aware of open vacancies withing the company, which minimizes the expectations of the job. Finally, it is faster and cheaper to recruit someome internally. One......

Words: 317 - Pages: 2

A Look at Stereotyping from Within

...A Look at Stereotyping from Within Dexter Robinson PSY400 July 03, 2012 Dr. Fathiah Inserto A Look at Stereotyping from Within Planet earth has approximately six billion people living on it and each individual is uniquely different. The differences can range from body shape, skin tone, religious preference, mental capacity, to how each individual processes life’s events. When people display their unique traits and characteristics it is a reminder that even though they may be grouped, each person is different and those differences often show in our social behavior. People are often confronted with the reality that there are some notable differences between and themselves and others. These differences may be social, economic, cultural, behavioral or religious but each difference distinctively sets each individual apart from the group. Ignoring unique cultural or racial differences between people can result in social setback, limiting an individual’s social awareness. Forcing everyone into the same cultural box for convenience sake does not promote understanding or tolerance, either. To gain a healthy respect for the uniqueness of all, we must first examine our own preconceived prejudices, our own overt or subliminal biases, and our own discriminatory attitudes that we aim toward others. In this paper I will explore those issues as well as how reactions to preconceived notions affect our thinking and how those reactions can affect social interaction between groups....

Words: 1603 - Pages: 7


...Case: 6:01-cv-00339-KKC-REW Doc #: 669 Filed: 03/01/10 Page: 1 of 17 - Page ID#: .,13376 ,,,:~™~ "' ^tt*** £0 m THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION. Plaintiff, v. WAL-MART STORES, INC. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) MAR - | 20tt) ATtnnw ^"^ CIVIL ACTION NO01-339-RICC Defendant CONSENT DECREE The United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (the XommissioiT or the "EEOC") commenced this action against Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. ("Wal-Mart") pursuant to Title VII of the Civil. Rights Act of 1964 and Title I of the Civil Rights Act of 1991 ("Title VII") to address allegations that Wal-Mart subjected a class of females to gender discrimination in hiring whenfillingopen orderfiller positions to Wal-Mart's Distribution Center No. 6097 ("DC 6097"), located in London, Kentucky. The Commission and Wal-Mart stipulate to the Court's jurisdiction over the parties. Further, the Commission and Wal-Mart desire to resolve Civil Action No. 01-339-KKC without the burden and expense of further litigation. As a result, and based on the pleadings and the record as a whole, the Court finds that: [i] the Court has jurisdiction over the parties and the subject matter of this action; [ii] the terms of this Decree are adequate, fair, reasonable, equitable and just; [hi] this Decree conforms with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and is not in derogation of the rights or privileges of any person; [iv]......

Words: 877 - Pages: 4

The Implications of the Diminution in Union Forms of Representation for the Efficiency of Employee Voice Within the Workplace

...The implications of the diminution in union forms of representation for the efficiency of employee voice within the workplace In the first decade of the 21st century, HR has been set a large significant number of issues and many subjects such as employee relationship, strategic HR approaches, employee rewarding, people resourcing, management ethics and so forth have attracted great deal of attention, concern and study to analysis their role, effect and contributions in organizations. Even though there are wide ranges of subjects playing different roles in human resource practices, an appreciation of operating the relationship between employees and employers has become an essential position of business and management recently. Traditionally, employers in employee relationship tried to maintain the control of the workforce with the goal of enhancing business performance. Clearly, if workers are treated fairly and respectively, in addition, they have appropriate influence on managerial decision-making, it could better for them perform improvably. Managers prefer grater work outcomes, nevertheless, it could bring employees’ requirements being disregarded or undermined (Budd, 2004). Therefore, employees bond to express their voice appropriately and their interests should be respected. The main way in which workers tend to voice their interests and representations in the workplace is to participate in collective unions so that they could in a position of greater strength; trade......

Words: 2795 - Pages: 12

Hiring Packet

...driver representing where they have been from date to date. Please complete this form and provide a signature/ date at bottom of page 7. Read “Driver Rights” provided by your company. 3. Page 8 - Previous Employer form – Only sign the top box on the first page where it states Applicant signature and date. Company / Supervisors will send out to the previous employers listed on driver’s application. 4. Page 9 – DISCLOSURE - sign and date bottom *Company is required to order and obtain a current MVR for driver prior to hiring or being moved into a driving position. Driver written authorization is required. 5. Page 10 top Record of Violations form – Fill in any moving traffic violations you have had within the past 12 months; provide a signature & date. If no violations check box. Page 10 bottom – Annual Review (SKIP) to be completed by supervisor with a current MVR. MVR=Motor Vehicle Report 6. Page 11 - Data Driver Sheet –fill in your name and SSN on top. On bottom half of form complete “Hours Of Service” section, provide the last 7 days, total hours worked both full time and part time jobs. It doesn’t matter if you were driving or not, while being employed. Must be completed with zeros and corresponding dates even if not working. Signature and date on bottom. Please follow other instructions on the form. 7. Page 12 - Pre-employment testing information (40.25(j)) by driver /applicant must be completed 8. Page 13 - Controlled Substance form – signature and date at bottom (if......

Words: 8061 - Pages: 33

Proper Hiring Techniques

...orientation manuals and found only three copies with several pages missing from each. Frustrated, he went for a quick walk. Upon his return to the office, he decided to check out the training room for the orientation. There, he found Joe, from technology services, setting up computer terminals. Carl reviewed the scheduling log and found that Joe had also reserved the room for the entire month of June for computer training seminars for the new database software implementation. The case study will identify the existing and recurring problems experienced by ABC Inc.’s HR Department focusing specifically on step-by-step instructions and scheduling of meeting space. Proper Hiring Process After interviewing Carl it was obvious that, despite the 6 month elapsed time, he is still experiencing difficulties with scheduling and completing the process of hiring and training recruits. There is a need for change within the organization that can be addressed with simple step-by-step instructions for the hiring process and a process for proper scheduling of the meeting room. Based on interviews with the Human Resources (HR) Director, Assistant Director, and two HR Generalists, the disorganization of the recruiting area is a long running one, covering the tenure of the previous three Recruiters, as well as the current one. The Operations Supervisor, Monica Carrolls, indicated that she had received no proactive updates from Carl on the progress of the recruitment process. She often......

Words: 1261 - Pages: 6

Leadership and Hiring

...Literature Review #2: Hiring/Firing decisions Genser, E. (2013). Hiring leaders. Leadership Excellence, 30(1), 19. Retrieved from: ABI/INFORM Complete. doi: 1270910265 Annotation Elaina Genser describes the precise method in which to accurately hire a good leader. While conducting a search employers must meet with the internal recruiter and construct a thorough job description. A simple application method is essential in order to receive maximum applications. The employer should acquire as many applicants and then narrow the candidates through the screening of resumes and references. Employers should not only interview external candidates, but should also approach qualified internal candidates. Promotion within the company saves money on the interview and training process that comes with new hires. When making a final decision for recruitment a successful evaluation is made by reaching a consensus and following protocol. Personal Reflection The first step the author advises is to meet with the company’s internal recruiter and discuss the position. Once a consensus is reached on the hiring requirements, a thorough job description should be introduced allowing suitable candidates to apply. I agree with this technique because it allows the applicant to decide whether they can fulfill the needs of the position. The executive must distinguish the leadership competencies that the company needs; and a candidate should be anticipated to follow the company’s......

Words: 451 - Pages: 2

"From Outside, in" by Barbara Melix

...“From Outside, In” By Barbara Melix Reflection/ Response In the article “From Outside, In” By Barbara Melix is about the use of different types of language. Melix points out Black English and Standard English are used in different contexts. Melix explains Black English is used as slang and Standard English is more formal or proper. Melix states that when African Americans speak Standard English instead of Black English they tend to be inferior because they feel embarrassed and ashamed to be their real selves. In the article Melix says, “ We were reserved, shy in the presence of those who owned and/or spoke the language.” She is saying that we hold back and are afraid to speak in front of those who spoke Standard English. African Americans are afraid to blurt out or say the wrong thing that will leave them feeling embarrassed or ashamed. As she goes deeper into the text she tells the importance language has on knowledge and power. In the article Melix states, “Speaking Standard English to whites was our way of demonstrating that we knew their language and could use it.” Melix is saying that we use Standard English in a professional environment or when we need to prove to white people we are just as educated as them. After reading I can relate to what Melix is stating in the article “From the Outside, In.” Learning to use language is not an easy task, when you grow up in a community that are comfortable with using one type of language: who don’t take......

Words: 614 - Pages: 3

Aspects of Internal & External Hiring

...The Aspects of Internal Hiring Vs. External Hiring: Pros and Cons Calvin Bowens WRTG 394 Advance Business Writing 1 October 2014 Professor John Ross Executive Summary This research provides an evaluation of the historic and current practices used to select internal employees for promotion in mid-level manager position versus selecting external candidates to fill those positions. Methods of this evaluation will include pros and cons, site managers and human resource team feedback, as well as, corporate leadership take on possible approaches. Results of this evaluation show that each hiring requirement is unique in nature when referring to positions of leadership. All members interviewed or who shared their insight stated having a clear understanding of what higher level leadership wants and demands must be established up front. Therefore, assumptions of these higher level expectations almost always end in failure of the newly hired external candidate or the internally hired employee. In addition, research finds current business practice being utilize in the company does not support selecting internally or externally. There are several areas requiring further attention and investigation, to include possible remedial training for human resource generalist and site managers for the sole purpose of building staff confidence and growing leaders from within. Corporate leaders have taken the hands-off approach to hiring mid-level managers. With that said, a clear and......

Words: 2536 - Pages: 11

Promotion from Within

...her own choices with that of the assessment centers. She can check the success of SSI’s predictions, by reviewing their assessment results. She can take these results and chart the ratings highest to lowest, leaving off the employee that had been given the promotion. Mrs. Pamplemousse should then begin comparing the employee’s job performance against their ratings. If SSI’s predictions are accurate, those employees with the higher ratings should out perform those with lower ratings. If she were to consistently find that the lower rated employee had out preformed the higher rated employee, she would need to reevaluate using SSI assessment process. Beyond this she could use meta-analysis, a form of validity generalization that is gaining acceptance. This will allow her to gather data from individual studies that examine the results of assessment center successes. The purpose is to obtain statistical confirmation of results and conclusions. It is assumed that by using this instead of paying for a complete evaluation of SSI and each of their tests would save the company money. Vin Pomme does bring up a good point. Although assessment centers have higher success rate in predicting job performance than just personality and cognitive ability test, the increase is fairly small, and with room for error the cost may outweigh the slightly higher success rate. Pamplemousse could consider have the personality and cognitive test preformed and use just these results to make her......

Words: 852 - Pages: 4

Penerapan “Hr from the Outside in” Bagi Kemajuan Organisasi Olahraga Pbsi

...PENERAPAN “HR FROM THE OUTSIDE IN” BAGI KEMAJUAN ORGANISASI OLAHRAGA PBSI Dunia olahraga Indonesia tengah menjadi sorotan, tanpa terkecuali cabang bulu tangkis dan organisasi kepengurusannya, Persatuan Bulu Tangkis Seluruh Indonesia (PBSI). Sayangnya, bukan prestasi membanggakan yang membuatnya menjadi sorotan melainkan merosotnya prestasi para atlet dan buruknya kinerja manajemen PBSI. Siapa sajakah yang berperan penting dalam mengelola sebuah organisasi keolahragaan? Kita mengenal beberapa komponen, diantaranya: manajer, pelatih dan program pelatihan, atlet/ pemain, sarana dan prasarana, pendanaan dan masyarakat. Sampai saat ini, banyak keluhan yang disebabkan oleh banyaknya pihak yang kurang kompeten masuk dalam jajaran manajemen PBSI, tumpang tindihnya wewenang, kurang maksimalnya program pelatihan, kurangnya kesejahteraan atlet, lemahnya kedisiplinan, dan sebagainya. Hal-hal tersebut adalah sebagian dari sekian banyak masalah yang kini dihadapi dunia bulu tangkis Indonesia dan PBSI. Menggerakkan organisasi keolahragaan, tidak kalah seriusnya dengan menjalankan organisasi bisnis maupun pemerintahan. Di dalamnya diperlukan kompetensi dan pengetahuan tentang bagaimana mengelola sumber daya terutama sumber daya manusia. Salah satu kelemahan manajemen organisasi keolahragaan Indonesia terletak pada kurang berkembangnya pengelolaan sumber daya tersebut sehingga organisasi menjadi kurang kompetitif. Strategi tidak hanya perlu diterapkan pada pertandingan......

Words: 443 - Pages: 2

Outside of the Box

...Step Outside Your World Adele Green COMM/315 September 12, 2011 Brian Lempke Step Outside Your World As an individual who is able to aid others in seeking shelter, food, clothing, and life sustaining items, I have the opportunity to communicate with women and children from different cities, states and countries seven days a week. I am exposed to different cultures, traditions, beliefs, and behaviors. The individuals I assist or help find assistance appear to view me as this well dressed professionally groomed person without any flaws. This activity was not a hard choice because in many ways I am different but the visible appearance others are use to will come off for this assignment. For this assignment I chose to expose an unforeseen experience during a fundraiser this weekend. I want to first mention I take pride in my appearance and I do not like to be embarrassed. At the fundraiser among people who have worked with me from the beginning of the organization and before hundreds of individuals who have chosen to take advantage of the resources Aiding Women and Children provide I displayed the bald head left from the chemotherapy treatments and removed the make-up that covers the burnt ashy skin left from the radiation treatments. The reason for choosing this activity was to hopefully inspire the women who complain they are not able to continue their education or get a job because of visible factors or factors others have no idea about.......

Words: 966 - Pages: 4


...Promote products and services BSBMKG413 Project Instruction You have been employed as the Product Promotional Manager. The organization that you work for has recently came up with a new product. The organization has assigned you to create the promotion for the product. You have an option of brand organization that you desire to do this project. Sony Xperia Z2 Promotional strategies Promotion is the method what I’m using to spread the word about my product and service to customers, stakeholders and the broader public. Once I’ve identified my target market, I’ll have a good idea of the best way to reach them, but most businesses use a mix of advertising, personal selling, referrals, sales promotion and public relations to promote their products or services. Sony will use these promotional strategie: * Social media * Mail order marketing * Product giveaways * Causes and charity * Press advertising * Outdoor (billboards, bus shelters etc….) * Cinema * Online advertising * Pricing strategies Sony will serve around city centrum area and huge malls. Our business is based on 2 simple facts: * We offer much more better technology compare to older Sony models. * We offer new functions which nobody else have on the market yet. Brief description of the products and services we will offer Sony Xperia Z2 offer a lot new features compate to older models and other brands on market such as......

Words: 1665 - Pages: 7

Millennial Generation from Hiring to Training

...DATE: 07/27/2011 Millennial Generation from hiring to training Student Name: SUJIN KIM Course Title: Leveraging Human Capital Introduction Millennial Generation in Korea, they are starting taking the lead in society. I am also same with them. My title is Millennial Generation from hiring to training. The reason why I chose as a topic is to share interesting information in way of hiring and training as though it is a short case study. I don’t know if how and what kinds of process other countries are carrying. I want to tell you current situation in workplace lively. I will describe current situation with a few examples focusing on new employees from my point of view as a work experienced person. I have organized my paper into two main sections. One is providing how to choose new employees and the second one is how to train for employees. I guarantee the following things are real Korean appearances now. Millennial Generation !? Hire like this ! I dreamed I could do significant projects perfectly and quickly in comfortable workplace when I get started my first job after graduation. As everyone knows, the high expectation comes great the disappointment. The companies should not leave as it is. They need to show reality of work environment to new employees. The young have a completely different set of values and expectations. If the companies do leave them, new employees would be frustrated and ready to leave their company.......

Words: 1480 - Pages: 6


...other means until a revised edition of the Catalog is published. The policies in this Catalog have been approved under the authority of the ECPI University Board of Trustees and, therefore, constitute official University policy. Students should become familiar with the policies in this Catalog. These policies outline both student rights and student responsibilities. The University reserves the right and authority at any time to alter any or all of the statements contained herein, to modify the requirements for admission and graduation, to change or discontinue programs of study, to amend any regulation or policy affecting the student body, to increase tuition and fees, to deny admission, to revoke an offer of admission and to dismiss from the University any student at any time, if it is deemed by the University to be in the best interest of the University, the University community, or the student to do so. The provisions of this publication are subject to change without notice and nothing in this publication may be considered as setting forth terms of a contract between a student or a prospective student and ECPI University. The electronic Catalog is the official version as it is updated on a regular basis. A printed Catalog is available for individuals who do not have access to the electronic Catalog. The following Catalog inserts are available upon request. Catalog Insert A– Continuing Education and Certificate Programs Catalog Insert E – Faculty and Key......

Words: 149595 - Pages: 599