Ratan Tata Was Moving the Group of Companies in Exactly the Opposite Direction from Where It Should Be Going?

In: Business and Management

Submitted By davidt1020
Words 862
Pages 4
Topic 2
Are Leaders Born or Made?
The belief that leaders are born rather than made dominated much of the late 19th century and early part of the 20th century... it was commonly believed that leaders, by virtue of their birth, were endowed with special qualities that allow them to lead others. (Nahavandi 2006)
Some of the traits/characteristics that were found by Bass (1990) to be common to successful leaders were:
• Capacity (intelligence, verbal skills, originality)

• Achievement (scholarship, knowledge, athletic accomplishment)

• Responsibility (dependability, initiative, self-confidence)

• Participation (sociability, cooperativeness)

• Status (socioeconomic position, popularity)

• Situation (interest in followers, objectives)

Later research by Kirkpatrick and Locke (1991) identified the following traits that differentiated leaders from non-leaders:
• Drive

• Desire to lead

• Honesty and integrity

• Self Confidence
10 © University of South Australia – IGSB

• Intelligence

• Job-relevant knowledge
There was a lack of consistency in these results.
It was noted that:
• behaviours can be observed

• behaviours are measurable and

• behaviours can be taught
At the same time, leaders were categorised as being autocratic, democratic or laissez-faire (Lewin 1938).
It was generally found that the democratic style was the most effective in employee productivity. However, it was also found that the democratic style could lead to less effective group performance than the autocratic style. task-related behaviours and relationship-related behaviours
Most recently, leadership theory dictates that leaders are most effective when they make their behaviour contingent upon situational forces, including the characteristics of group members (DuBrin et al, 2006). This is…...

Similar Documents

Tata Case

...1. Which, if any, of the following initiatives undertaken by Ratan Tata do you think were good ideas? a) Creation of a Group Brand b) Building of equity interlocks among the Tata companies c) Sale of a part of Tata Industries Limited to the Hong Kong-based Jardine Matheson group d) Revitalisation of Tata Administrative Services 2. What do you think of some critics’ opinion that Ratan Tata was moving the group of companies in exactly the opposite direction from where it should be going? The Indian economy following the 1991 crisis swiftly moved away from central planning economy towards market-based economy with the government having less intervention and control. As a result, companies were operating in what is called emerging markets. Khanna & Palepu (1997, pp.41-2) describe emerging markets as hardly uniform that lack in providing the institutions vital for basic business operations. Companies that operate in such environment must adapt their strategies to fit their institutional context. Appendix 1 of the case study clearly shows market failures of Indian economy in mid 1990s compared to the UK and US. Some of the market failures include:  information problems (e.g. limited phone lines, TVs, newspapers)  capital markets problems (e.g. low bank assets, limited watchdog bodies, limited access to local capital markets and market information asymmetries)  political and risk factors problems (e.g. corruption, low efficiency of judicial system, state......

Words: 1223 - Pages: 5

Tata Group

...Tata Group is following policy of growth strategy based on Mergers & Acquisitions. So, Corus takeover is a part of a whole series of mega acquisitions in diverse areas since 2000. Tata Steel's acquisition of Corus of the UK clearly reinforces the strategic logic dictating `consolidation' in the highly fragmented steel industry. The historic merger of Arcelor and Mittal Steel laid the foundation for this deal. For Tata Steel, which has been pursuing inorganic growth in the Asian region for a while, the move into Europe appears to go well with its strategy of global growth. Tata steel chose the equity mode to enter the European market. Equity mode or Foreign Direct Investment is the principle way in which firms enter and compete in the modern global economy. Acquisition is the part of FDI. The acquirer inherits the company’s strategic assets (managerial, technological, and marketing resources), without having to build them from scratch, as would be the case when setting up overseas operations through Greenfield investment. Increasingly, acquiring strategic assets have become a motivation for OFDI from emerging economies Tata have chosen Acquisition for many reasons. Some of these reasons can be explained by theory, while others not. Now we will discuss the prime motives that encourage Tata to adopt aggressive Acquisition policy while entering European Steel Market. The main advantages to Tata by choosing Acquisition are as follows: Economy of scale: This......

Words: 860 - Pages: 4

Tata Group- Corporate Restructuring

...Tata Group: Transforming the Sleeping Elephant “A company does not become global by simply participating in geographical markets around the world. The objective of globalization is to become globally competitive, leverage global opportunities and have the required global capabilities. It implies an organization, which employs talented people without reference to nationality. We are in the process of acquiring such competitive position and global capabilities”. Ratan Tata, Chairman, Tata Sons (Hindustan Times, September 5, 2004). “Despite popular perception Ratan Tata has more than lived up to JRD’s vision and expectations”. Deepakh Parekh, Chairman, HDFC, (India Today, February, 2003). The unfolding of a crisis After proposing the Strategic Plan in 1991, Ratan Tata observed: “I think we are in many more businesses than we should have been in and were perhaps not concerned about our market position in each of those businesses. I think the needs today are that we define our businesses much more articulately and that we remain focused rather than diffused, and that we become more aggressive than we used to be, much more market driven, much more concerned about our customer satisfaction (HBS Working Paper, 9-798-037).” Ratan Tata on being questioned in an interview regarding – what criteria he will choose in deciding what to keep and what not to, in his groups’ portfolio restructuring exercise? To this he replied, “One is certainly going to be: can we be in the first three in......

Words: 8239 - Pages: 33

Tata Motors Company Analysis

... Tata Motors, Ltd., the automobile division of the global conglomerate the Tata Group, was India’s leading commercial vehicle manufacturer and the third largest passenger vehicle maker in 2012; culminating into unprecedented growth in several areas and, as mentioned in the case study presented by Turnipseed and Gamble of The University of South Alabama, helped to make Tata India’s highest revenue generating automobile company (as cited in Thompson, Peteraf, Gamble, & Strickland, 2013, p. C-246). In the international marketplace, Tata is also very competitive, particularly in China and emerging economies such as Brazil and several countries in Africa. Although the company’s 2012 annual report, along with the analysis conducted by Turnipseed and Gamble, provide an optimistic view of the company’s long-term fiscal health and ability to continue to compete; further research and analysis indicate several challenges and a variety of obstacles for Tata to overcome if it is to become “a global contender in the automobile industry.” The case study that follows offers insight into the macroeconomic environment in which Tata operates, specifically in India, the competitive forces applying pressure on, not just Tata, but the global auto industry as a whole and, finally, a brief analysis of the firm’s financial performance over the past five years. Subsequent to this, we shall uncover the key success factors for Tata and its core competencies and deficiencies; what the company does...

Words: 2100 - Pages: 9

Ratan Tata

...Management approach, companies can choose to either venture their business towards the Global or Regional strategy. The Global Integration strategy looks at production and distribution of products and services of a homogenous type and quality on a worldwide basis. National Responsiveness strategy requires understanding of individual consumer tastes imposed by autonomous governments and agencies. To further understand the Global and National strategies, we look into the two-dimension matrix below. (textbook, pg277) Global Strategy International Strategy Transnational Strategy Multi-domestic Strategy Global Integration High Low National Responsiveness High Low Quadrant 1 – Global Strategy, High requirement for integration and low awareness of differentiation. Based on price competition, entry strategy used it often mergers and acquisition. Quadrant 2 – International Strategy. Low requirement for centralised quality check and strategic decision making eliminating the need to adapt to individual countries. Mixed strategy combining low demand for integration and responsiveness. Quadrant 3 – Transnational Strategy. High requirement for integration and differentiation. Emphasizing both global integration and local responsiveness. Quadrant 4 – Multi-domestic Strategy. High requirement for differentiation but low concern for integration. Emphasize on local adaption. 2.1 ANALYSIS Adaption from the Case Studies and Research Cases Tata Group uses two......

Words: 2785 - Pages: 12

Moving from Team to Group

...restatement of the document’s purpose, scope, methods, results, conclusions, findings, and recommendations. The Executive Summary should be proportional to the length of your paper. For purposes of the Capstone paper, we recommend a 500-word Executive Summary.     Introduction The introduction provides the reader with background information for the research reported in the paper. Its purpose is to establish a framework for the research, so that the reader can understand how it is related to other research. The Introduction has multiple purposes, namely to create reader interest in the topic, establish the problem that leads to the study, place the study within the larger context of the scholarly literature, and reach out to a specific audience.     Literature Review The review of previous research accomplishes several purposes. It shares with the reader the results of other studies that are closely related to the study being reported, it relates the study to the larger, ongoing dialogue in the literature about the topic, and it provides a framework for establishing the importance of the study. It can serve as a benchmark for comparing the results of the study with other findings.     Methodology This section specifies the type of research design utilized in the paper, such as the approach to data collection, analysis, and report writing. It should detail the context of the research, e.g. type of organization, jurisdiction, indicate how subjects were selected, e.g.......

Words: 619 - Pages: 3

Evaluation of Tata Group

...and evaluation of the business model of Tata Group Introduction In the following case we will briefly analyze and evaluate the business model of Tata Group, an Indian giant that is moving into a global powerhouse. We will firstly use the SWOT analysis tool in order to understand the internal and external environment. Then we will strategically position the group with the help of the Porters Generic Strategy which will be followed by an overview of the VRIO model and conclude with looking into the croups portfolio with the Boston Consulting Group (BCG). According to Johnson et all described in their book Exploring Corporate Strategy, ”A business model describes the structure of product, service and information flows and the roles of the participating parties” For example a it is how the description of raw material is being converted to a final product and transferred to the final consumer. SWOT Analysis SWOT analysis is a tool that helps us develop strategic development by creating strategic options and evaluate future planning. This is achieved by identifying and analyzing the most important issues in a company’s environment as well as the strategic capability of an organization. Strengths: * Innovation is one step that Tata has advantage because, the lot of companies the group has helps each other and makes it easier to develop. * Resources are easier to being accessed due to the fact that Tata has a wide range of companies in their portfolio that generate......

Words: 2302 - Pages: 10

Strategic Development Tata Motors

... TATA MOTORS Introduction: Tata Motors Limited (formerly TELCO, short for Tata Engineering and Locomotive Company) is an Indian multinational automotive manufacturing company headquartered in Mumbai, Maharashtra, India and a subsidiary of the Tata Group. Its products include passenger cars, trucks, vans, coaches, buses, construction equipment and military vehicles. It is the world's seventeenth-largest motor vehicle manufacturing company, fourth-largest truck manufacturer and second-largest bus manufacturer by volume. Tata Motors has auto manufacturing and assembly plants in Jamshedpur, Pantnagar, Lucknow, Sanand, Dharwad and Pune in India, as well as in Argentina, South Africa, Thailand and the United Kingdom. It has research and development centres in Pune, Jamshedpur, Lucknow and Dharwad, India, and in South Korea, Spain, and the United Kingdom. Tata Motors' principal subsidiaries include the British premium car maker Jaguar Land Rover (the maker of Jaguar, Land Rover and Range Rover cars) and the South Korean commercial vehicle manufacturer Tata Daewoo. Tata Motors has a bus manufacturing joint venture with Marcopolo S.A. (Tata Marcopolo), a construction equipment manufacturing joint venture with Hitachi (Tata Hitachi Construction Machinery), and a joint venture with Fiat which manufactures automotive components and Fiat and Tata branded vehicles. Founded in 1945 as a manufacturer of locomotives, the company manufactured its first......

Words: 8963 - Pages: 36

Salesforce.Com Where the Company Came from and Where to Go

...sales) and all others. The top ten vendors worldwide generated $10.9B in sales alone in 2012. Marc Benioff (current president and CEO) founded the company in San Francisco in 1999 with a vision to create an on-demand customer relationship management (CRM) solution that would completely change the market model and replace traditional enterprise software technology. Later on, this concept delivered immediate benefits to companies of all sizes at reduced risks and costs. Benioff is now regarded as one of the pioneers of cloud computing and has been driving businesses to transform into customer companies by covering social and mobile cloud technologies to connect with customers, partners, employees and even products in new ways. In this case study, we will approach the success of Salesforce.com by using the “6 Paths Framework” (6 innovation strategies). The 6 Paths Framework 1. Industry (looks across alternative industries) Benioff is credited with pioneering the concept of delivering sales, marketing, and customer applications, through a simple web site when the competitors of the company were offering the same solutions through client software on user desktops and traditional enterprise technology. Competitors like Oracle, Microsoft, etc., that dominated the enterprise software market, had provided almost all the large companies in the world with their products and services. Salesforce.com innovated a new way of offering by providing a web based solution with a 30 day......

Words: 2900 - Pages: 12

Where Will Tomorrow Leaders Come from

...Where Will We Find Tomorrow’s Leaders? Paul Hemp FROM THE JANUARY 2008 ISSUE SUMMARY SAVE SHARE COMMENT TEXT SIZE PRINT 8.95 BUY COPIES VIEW MORE FROM THE January 2008 Issue EXPLORE THE ARCHIVE RECOMMENDED Discovering Your Authentic Leadership (HBR Bestseller) LEADERSHIP & MANAGING PEOPLE HBR ARTICLE William W. George, Peter Sims, Andrew N. McLean, David Mayer, Diana Mayer 8.95 ADD TO CART SAVE SHARE HBR Tools: Better Meetings ORGANIZATIONAL DEVELOPMENT PRESS TOOLKIT 29.95 ADD TO CART SAVE SHARE First, Let's Fire All the Managers LEADERSHIP & MANAGING PEOPLE HBR ARTICLE Gary Hamel 8.95 ADD TO CART SAVE SHARE For the past half century, there has been consensus about the kinds of places effective business leaders are formed: companies like General Electric and Procter & Gamble, high-powered consulting firms like McKinsey, elite business schools like Harvard and Wharton, the military. But it’s a different world now. Markets and workforces are increasingly global and diverse. Change is so rapid that one leader can’t hope to keep abreast of all developments, much less be responsible for the innovation needed to keep ahead of them. Decision making is broadly distributed across an organization, and collaboration is required with numerous parties outside it. So it’s worth reexamining our image of the ideal business leader and how and where a person will acquire the attributes needed to become one. We may find that it’s......

Words: 4278 - Pages: 18

Tata Group

...The Tata Group has been transformed from a risk-averse, slow-moving giant into a more dynamic and aggressive conglomerate. How much of such a transformation can be attributed to one individual? Discuss the role of the leader in initiating and managing change. Much of the transformation in the Tata Group could be attributed to Ratan Tata. He took several initiatives – rightsizing, exiting some businesses, injecting fresh talent, and changing the culture – to effect a transformation. He turned around some businesses and revamped the operations of several others. He also renamed some group companies and made them adopt a common logo. He integrated the various businesses and transformed the Tata Group companies into leaner and nimbler companies. 1. Based on the SWOT analysis provided in the case, what are the two or three factors that Mistine should stress in its strategic planning as it looks to continue its growth and dominance in the Thai market? How can Mistine match its strengths with its market opportunities to create competitive advantage moving forward? After having analyzed the information about Mistine’s domestic market, there are several problems that need to be managed including a high employee turnover rate, limited channels of distribution, and an increased competition in the industry. Employee turnover: The rate of salesperson turnover at Mistine is about 200%, which is very high. The reason is due to several reasons. Most of Mistine’s salespersons sell......

Words: 448 - Pages: 2

Ratan Tata

...India’s biggest conglomerate – Tata Group. Ratan Tata joined the company after college and took over his late uncle’s business 16 years ago. He is involved in more issues than he should be. The authoritarian Tata is the chairman of key units including Tata Motors and Tata Steel and is involved in all major deals and making all the key decision. 2. SECONDARY PROBLEMS 2.1 Short Term A bid for Jaguar and Land Rover might present an even more daunting challenge for Ratan Tata. It would be an uphill climb to restore Jaguar’s luxury cachet, which was damaged by sharing basic designs with Ford. As the organization gets bigger and more diverse, talent and retaining the value system will pose the biggest challenge in Tata Group (Engardio and Lakshman 2007) 2.2 Long Term Succession “is a problem”. Ratan Tata is 69 years old, not married and has two dogs at his beachfront home he designed himself. He commands most Tata companies, which makes his failure to designate a successor all the more disconcerting. In Asian culture, the eldest son will take over the family business, however Tata is not married therefore he does not have any family members to take over his empire. Ratan, who is single and childless, could be the last Tata to oversee the group. His younger brother and three half-sisters aren’t involved in Tata business; his reclusive half-brother is unclear whether he’s tycoon timber (Engardio and Lakshman 2007). Ratan Tata public listed his companies, which also means......

Words: 1994 - Pages: 8

Ratan Tata

...Tata OUTLINE FOR CASE ANALYSIS AND REPORTS 1. Source Problems: This is a general statement of the underlying, fundamental problem or core issue. It is important to distinguish between symptoms of the problem, and the problem itself. Frequently the source problem precedes the current problems in the case. (one short paragraph) (medical example: tonsillitis) 2. Secondary Problems: These are more specific, current and observable problems and derive from the source problem. They frequently are the problems immediately evident in the case. Do not write three sections: all problems should be listed under short or long term. (Three quarters of a page). (medical example: fever, loss of appetite, cough) Short Term: Current problems of recent origin, which can be solved within a period of months without major commitments of capital, technology, finance or managerial effort. (business example: overstocking, high prices, labour shortage) 2.1 2.2 2.3 Long Term: Problems which have existed for years, and which involve long-term trends in the internal or external environment. They will reuire solutions spread over a period longer than, say, a year, and may demand major allocations of capital, technology, finance and managerial effort. (business example: obsolete products, out-pf-date production process technology, lack of adequate plant capacity) ...

Words: 954 - Pages: 4

Ratan Tata: Leading the Tata Group Into the 21st Century

...Ratan Tata: Leading the Tata Group into the 21st Century 1. The Tata Group has been transformed from a risk-averse, slow-moving giant into a more dynamic and aggressive conglomerate. How much of such a transformation can be attributed to one individual? Discuss the role of the leader in initiating and managing change. Answer The Tata Group transformation can be greatly attributed to the vision and execution of Ratan Tata. He was greatly responsible for the tremendous transformation because he was able to take his vision for the group and transformed it into a reality. By enforcing a mandatory retirement age policy which removed a lot of top management, who were challenging the core functions of the group and hindering growth, Ratan Tata implemented this as one of the first major changes in is rein. By replacing these individuals, he made a way for young fresh talent to bring new ideas to the group. In addition he implemented and created a Group Executive Office whose members were represented on the boards of the Tata companies, in addition to Tata Business Excellence Model (TBEM) that he introduced which was the Tata Group’s largest change initiative. The Tata Business Excellence Model (TBEM) was implemented and maintained through Tata Quality Management Services and its specific processes. Ratan Tata demonstrated a democratic leadership style that entailed openness to ideas with the group. With this his leadership approach he encouraged the executives and managers to be...

Words: 853 - Pages: 4

House of Tata

...HOUSE OF TATA The Business Agricultural Products Base Metals Non-Metallic Mineral Products Chemicals Construction & Allied Activities Electrical and Non-Electrical Machinery Electricity & Non-Conventional Energy Electronics Services Shipping & Exports  Hotels Financial Drilling Real Estate Other Watches Pulp & Paper Press Engineering & Locomotive Vertically integrated Focus in domestic market (India) Resources Financial Capital  Managerial Expertise  Business Network  Established brand Structures, Systems & Processes Corporate communication Weekly cross-company director’s meetings Autonomous business unit operations Uniform Policies across the Tata Group SBU’s annual contribution system (franchise) J.R.D. Quality Value Award Uniform code of conduct High quality Ethical business practices Recruitment process Hand picking chairmen Head hunting talented individuals for SBUs (Tata Administrative Services) Controlling interest 0.01 to 15% in current SBUs  25-50% in new ventures Investors with +26% have legal right to block take over resolutions Strategy .Convert Tata Group into a tighter, leaner organization to deliver a stronger collective identity. Synergize Merge Tata’s 3 electric companies Divest Loss Making Tata Oil Mills Company Ltd. Increase SBU’s control/ownership Purchase equity in SBU’s Branding SBUs adherence via contribution system Promote brand in foreign......

Words: 951 - Pages: 4