Valuation of Friendly Cards Case

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Capnziggy
Words 2617
Pages 11
Final Case: Friendly Cards, Inc.
FINAN 4210
Lutz

Jonathan Matsen
05/01/2013

Problem Identification
Wendy Beaumont, president of Friendly Cards, is currently faced with 3 time sensitive issues that need to me dealt with immediately. As a relatively small company in the fiercely competitive greeting card industry, Ms. Beaumont must make some quick yet intelligent decisions to ensure the continued success of her company.
To be more specific, she must decide upon:
 The investment in equipment to enable the company to make rather than buy their own envelopes  The acquisition of Creative Designs Inc., a small Midwestern manufacturer of studio cards  The possibility of going to the market to raise additional equity capital in order to relieve pressure on its financial position
Identification of Relevant Facts
Friendly’s position in the industry
As of early 1988, the main issues facing the greeting card industry were:
 Continued industry consolidation (a decline of 15% per decade since 1954)
 Cyclical revenues
 The presence of high fixed costs
Threat of Industry Consolidation
Since its inception in 1978, Friendly Cards reacted to the looming threat of industry consolidation by rapidly expanding internally and through various acquisitions. These acquisitions allowed Friendly to access new markets and demographics that would have been previously unavailable to them. For example, through their acquisition of a California firm, the company gained West Coast distribution access and a more profitable form of distribution that cut out the middle-man/men (which ate away at profit margins), and a new branding opportunity through the creation of “Friendly Artists”.
Friendly also diversified their product offerings with a full line of greeting cards (1200 designs) for the upcoming 1988 year, which was uncharacteristic of a small company. They…...

Similar Documents

Friendly Cards Case Analysis

...Investment Decisions Summary of Facts Friendly Cards, Inc. (first named Beaumont Greeting Card Co.) is a greeting card company started in 1978, in New York City by Wendy Beaumont. The company has experienced rapid growth, acquiring like companies and expanding its market base. The company became public through a stock offering at $3 per share. From an operational viewpoint, Friendly cards performed all production at its plant in Reading, Connecticut. Company sales include nearly 30% from Christmas sales, 25% from Valentines sales and about 45% from average every day and spring holiday sales. The company reports low returns expense, as packages sold to stores were not returnable. Overall operations are well monitored under a tiered organizational structure. Wendy Beaumont, the company’s president is looking to further expand and has asked the advice of friend and financial consultant, Amy McConville to review a potential acquisition or partnership. The prospects will elevate some of the president’s concerns for financing. In her own words, Ms. Beaumont expressed that the cost of financing growth right now was high and Friendly Card's projects 20% growth over the next year and even more in subsequent years. Further stating, the company had never been without financing problems and had always been capital intensive relying on strong relations with its banks and suppliers in realizing success. Still, Friendly’s bankers have begun to feel uneasy regarding the......

Words: 3519 - Pages: 15

Creme Case Valuation

...have seen innumerable social innovations that have moved from margins to mainstream. These include the invention and spread of trade unions and cooperatives, which radically reshaped them for the grim factories of 19th century industry; providing collective insurance against sickness and poverty; the spread of new models of universities in 19th century. In 19th and early 20th century Britain and civil society pioneered the most influential new models of childcare (Barnardos), housing (Peaboy) and social care (Rowntree). With the growth in new breed of social innovators and entrepreneurs over the next 20 years the biggest growth in OECD countries is likely to come in health, education and care, whose share of GDP are already much greater than card or telecoms, steel or biotech. Social and Economic Problems in Spain Labor Market Inefficiency: Due to global financial and economic crisis youth unemployment (those aged 16 to 24) reached a staggering 51 percent in mid-2012 (though this figure does not take into account those who are studying and others not actively seeking work. Nearly 2 million of the 6 million without work have been unemployed for more than two years and are no longer entitled to unemployment benefits. Only 9 percent have a chance of finding work, compared to 30 percent five years ago, according to the employment agency association AGETT. Domestic Violence: Last year in Spain, 73 women died at home at the hands of their partners — roughly, one every......

Words: 1070 - Pages: 5

Walmart, Valuation Case Study

...S VALUING WAL-MART STOCK1 w 906N09 Professor Stephen R. Foerster prepared this case solely to provide material for class discussion. The author does not intend to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a managerial situation. The author may have disguised certain names and other identifying information to protect confidentiality. Ivey Management Services prohibits any form of reproduction, storage or transmittal without its written permission. Reproduction of this material is not covered under authorization by any reproduction rights organization. To order copies or request permission to reproduce materials, contact Ivey Publishing, Ivey Management Services, c/o Richard Ivey School of Business, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada, N6A 3K7; phone (519) 661-3208; fax (519) 661-3882; e-mail cases@ivey.uwo.ca. Copyright © 2006, Ivey Management Services Version: (A) 2009-09-23 In early January 2006, Rachel Martin was examining Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (Wal-Mart) stock and its valuation. As an investment advisor with a major brokerage firm, Martin gave investment suggestions and helped clients manage their portfolios. Some of her clients had Wal-Mart stock in their portfolios, and Martin wondered whether to recommend the stock to any of her new clients or to existing clients who did not currently have Wal-Mart in their portfolios. BACKGROUND OF WAL-MART STORES, INC. Based in Bentonville, Arkansas, and founded by the legendary Sam......

Words: 5056 - Pages: 21

Friendly Cards Inc

...Friendly Cards Liu Xing 1. In order to calculate the WACC of Creative Design, we need to estimate the beta first. We can calculate the beta(e) from the weighted beta(e)s of the industry. According to Exhibit 5: βe of American Greetings=1.07 and the net income is 33.4, βe of Gibson Greetings=0.93 and the net income is 24.1. So we estimate theβe of CD: 1.07*33.4/(33.4+24.1)+0.93*24.1/(33.4+24.1)=1.01 Re of CD=Rf+βe(Rm-Rf)=8.4%+1.01*7%=15.47% According to Exhibit 7, the Debt of CD=2250 D/V=2250/4500=50% From Exhibit 6, the interest of 1987 is 100, Rd=100/2250=4.44%, Rtax=95/238=40% WACC=15.47%*50%+4.44%*50 %*(1-40%)=9.07% If we consider the CD’s Equity as it’s market value, which is 11 times of it’s 1987 earnings, the Equity=171*11=1881, the D/V will be bigger, and WACC will be smaller. 2. The purpose we do the projection is to determine whether we should acquire CD, so we need to consider the improvements Friendly intends, they are: Reduce COGS by 5%, other expense by 10%, and sales increase by 6% per year. Using the COGS/Net Sale and Total Expense/Net Sales of 1987, we can estimate that of 1990. When estimate the debt, we use the same rate as Interest/(COGS+Expense) in1987,because Debt is more closely related to the COGS and Expense. Then the income statement of 1990 is as follow: | Income Statement |1987 |1988 |1989 |1990 | |Net sales |5,000 |5,000 |5,300 |5,618 | |COGS |3,075 |2,921 |3,097 |3,282 | | Gross profit |1,925 |2,079 |2,203......

Words: 731 - Pages: 3

American Express Card Case

...Jake Wright HW #1 6/23/14 Answer the following two questions based on The American Express Card Case: 1. American Express was able to expand its merchant mix over time despite charging merchants a higher discount rate than Visa and MasterCard. Why were merchants willing to start accepting American Express cards? Merchants were willing to start accepting American Express cards because of the patrons that were associated with those cards. The case mentions that the annual average purchase volume for an AmEx card holder ($8,360) was substantially higher than that of Visa or Mastercard, $2470 and $1960, respectively. This meant that the AmEx card holders were more likely to spend more at locations. AmEx used the higher discount rates to study the purchase habits and inclinations of card holders. These studies led to more targeted promotions, which allowed merchants who accepted AmEx to bring in more patrons who were more likely to purchase more at their locations. 2. How does American Express create and sustain a key competitive advantage over major competitors such as Visa and MasterCard? In order to create and sustain a competitive advantage over its competitors AmEx targeted a certain customer and their “lifestyle.” Instead of targeting customers that were transaction oriented, AmEx targeted customers that were “high wallet” consumers, with spending of over $30,000. These consumers were identified as travelers, liked to be different and liked......

Words: 460 - Pages: 2

Friendly Card

... ESTIMATION OF GROWTH RATES The value of a firm is ultimately determined not by current cash flows but by expected future cash flows. The estimation of growth rates in earnings and cash flows is therefore central to doing a reasonable valuation. Growth rates can be obtained in many ways: they can be based upon past growth; drawn from estimates made by other analysts who follow the firm; or related to the firm's fundamentals. Since each of these approaches yields some valuable information, it makes sense to blend them to arrive at one composite growth rate to use in the valuation. This chapter examines different approaches to estimating future growth, and discusses the determinants of growth. Question 1 - Arithmetic and Geometric Means The following are the earnings per share of Thermo Electron, a company that designs cogeneration and resource recovery plants, from 1987 to 1992: |Year |EPS | |1987 |0.67 | |1988 |0.77 | |1989 |0.90 | |1990 |1.10 | |1991 |1.31 | |1992 |1.51 | A. Estimate the arithmetic average growth rate in earnings per share from 1987 to 1992. B. Estimate the geometric average growth rate in earnings per share from 1987 to 1992. C. Why are the growth rates different? Question 2 - Linear and Log-linear Models of Earnings Growth Consider again the example of Thermo Electron, described in the prior......

Words: 1084 - Pages: 5

Card Case

...T:8.5” The Card for International Students Enjoy great rewards while building your U.S. credit history Enjoy great rewards with the Citi ThankYou Preferred Card for International Students. ® The Citi ThankYou® Preferred Card for College Students comes with Citi ThankYou® Rewards, the program where you can redeem points you earn on purchases for gift cards and merchandise, or use towards your student loan payment or for charitable donations. You can also redeem points for travel rewards such as for tickets on any airline with no blackout dates through the ThankYou Travel Center. C_TY_Preferred_EMV_W_MNLW_15-PID 84 Citi ThankYou® Preferred Card for International Students Entertainment T:11” Dining Other Purchases Citi ThankYou® Preferred Card. Earn points for the rewards you really want. Special offer for new accounts:  Earn 2,500 bonus ThankYou® Points after you spend $500 in your first 3 months of cardmembership.1  0% Intro APR on purchases for 7 months. After that, the variable APR for purchases will be 13.99%. The APR will vary with the market based on the Prime Rate.2  No annual fee.2  Travel with ease and enjoy global acceptance when you use your card with chip. With the Citi ThankYou Preferred Card, you enjoy:   Earn 2 ThankYou Points per $1 spent for dining at restaurants and on entertainment and 1 ThankYou Point per $1 spent on other purchases.1 No expiration and no limit to the......

Words: 5487 - Pages: 22

Valuation

...Acquisitions seem to offer firms a short cut to their strategic objectives, but the process has its costs. In this chapter, we examine the four basic steps in an acquisition, starting with establishing an acquisition motive, continuing with the identification and valuation of a target firm, and following up with structuring and paying for the deal. The final, and often the most difficult, step is making the acquisition work after the deal is consummated. Background on Acquisitions When we talk about acquisitions or takeovers, we are talking about a number of different transactions. These transactions can range from one firm merging with another 1 2 firm to create a new firm to managers of a firm acquiring the firm from its stockholders and creating a private firm. We begin this section by looking at the different forms taken by acquisitions, continue the section by providing an overview on the acquisition process and conclude by examining the history of the acquisitions in the United States Classifying Acquisitions There are several ways in which a firm can be acquired by another firm. In a merger, the boards of directors of two firms agree to combine and seek stockholder approval for the combination. In most cases, at least 50% of the shareholders of the target and the bidding firm have to agree to the merger. The target firm ceases to exist and becomes part of the acquiring firm; Digital Computers was absorbed by Compaq after it was acquired in 1997. In a consolidation,......

Words: 21338 - Pages: 86

Visa Card Case

...Read the case titled "Starbucks, Bank One, and Visa Launch Starbucks Card Duetto Visa" in the Resources and address the following components in your assignment: • Answer discussion questions 2 and 4 at the end of the case. 2. Build the management-research question hierarchy for this project. Step 1: Management Dilemma Is there a brand fit between credit card and Starbucks? How does the customer value the different benefits being offered by the Starbucks Duetto Visa card? How does the customer value "the give back to the community component"? Step 2: Management Questions If there is a match between the brand and the customers value the benefits of Starbucks Duetto Visa card, the card should be launched to as large an audience as possible. Step 3: Research Questions Starbucks should go in for the full launch of Starbucks Duetto Visa card. Starbucks should go in for a limited launch of Starbucks Duetto Visa card Starbucks should launch the Starbucks Duetto Visa card without give-back-to-the community component. Step 4: Investigation Questions Does Starbucks Duetto Visa card clash with the image of Starbucks? How much do the benefits of Starbucks Duetto Visa card appeal to the customers? How much do the planned give back to the community component appeals to the customers of Starbucks Duetto Visa card? Step 5: Measurement Question What is the extent to which the perception of Starbucks is hurt by Starbucks Duetto Visa card. In dollars what is the perceived value......

Words: 840 - Pages: 4

Apple Valuation Case

...management, forecasting and replenishment. With our continued focus on the stores, we provided additional technology improvements designed to help store associates perform their tasks and improve customer service. In fiscal 2009, we equipped 1,977 stores with new servers, 211 stores with new computers, registers and printers and 63 stores with new paint dispensers. Credit Services. We offer private label credit products in our stores through a third-party credit provider to professional, D-I-Y and D-I-F-M customers. In fiscal 2009, approximately 2.8 million new The Home Depot 3 private label credit accounts were opened, and the total number of The Home Depot active account holders was approximately 12 million. Private label credit card sales accounted for approximately 25% of store sales in fiscal 2009. In fiscal 2008, Home Depot renegotiated and extended the term of the primary contracts governing the private label program. In fiscal 2009, we continued to benefit from our new contracts which established a ceiling for the cost of credit for the program while retaining the ability for portfolio performance improvements to lower the cost of credit. Logistics. We continued our supply chain transformation in fiscal 2009 to ensure product availability for customers, effective use of our investment in inventory and low total supply chain costs. Across our supply chain operations in the U.S., Canada and Mexico, we restructured our distribution center network to......

Words: 32934 - Pages: 132

Balance Score Card Case Verisson

...HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT I Case Study Homework Galderma Galderma es una empresa Farmacéutica que se especializa en la distribución y producción de productos dermatológicos esta cuenta con diversas filiales alrededor del mundo desde Europa hasta Sudamérica. (Galderma.cl) En el año 1996 Galderma se concreta como entidad legal en Chile, después de la separación de la división dermatológica con Alcon Laboratorios. En la actualidad la compañía cuenta con un equipo que trabaja muy motivado para mantener y mejorar el posicionamiento de la compañía en Chile. La empresa ha tenido un crecimiento durante todos los años de funcionamiento, satisfaciendo las necesidades de sus clientes (dermatólogos, pacientes) (Galderma.cl). Para el curso de Human Resource Management I, se hizo una consultoría a la empresa el cual consistía en Elaborar una guía de entrenamiento para sus vendedores, con el propósito de mejorar las habilidades y capacidades de estos, causando así mejoras en la ventas de la empresa y generar un mayor posicionamiento en el mercado Chileno. Para que este entrenamiento cumpla con los objetivos principales de la empresa, posteriormente se sugerirá una guía para la elaboración de un Balance Scorecard ya que la empresa actualmente no cuenta con uno. Balance Scorecard- Galderma Los pasos a seguir para la implementación de un Balance Scorecard son : 1. Realizar la definición estratégica Este paso es fundamental ya que sentará las bases sobre las cuales se......

Words: 902 - Pages: 4

Wal-Mart Valuation Case

...Valuing Walmart - 2010 Introduction This case requires the valuation of Walmart stock as of February 2010 based on company and market data up to 2010. Determination of the stock value will aid in the decision to recommend Walmart stock as an investment to clients. The valuation of stock is based on estimations of various parameters using various prediction models. Several models are available to aid in estimating stock prices and they are utilized herein. The dividend discount model, future dividends and a terminal value, the three-stage approach and use of P/E ratios are all utilized in this analysis to best determine a buy/hold/sell recommendation for clients. Dividends in Perpetuity The Dividend Discount Model (DDM) is one way to assess the worth of Walmart’s stock price. This model assumes that the current value of Walmart’s stock is the present value of future expected dividends, discounted by the investor’s expected rate of return. A perpetuity is an annuity that has no end, or in other words, a stream of cash payments that continue for an indefinite period of time as seen in Exhibit 1, Figure 1. The perpetuity relationship is stock price is equal to expected dividends divided by the investor’s required rate of return minus the perpetual dividend growth rate as illustrated in Exhibit 1, Equation 1. The input variables needed to calculate the current value of a firm’s stock price are dividend growth, expected dividend, and the investor’s......

Words: 2395 - Pages: 10

Fb Business Valuation

...BUSINESS VALUATION Dt: March, 10, 2011 FACEBOOK Facebook Business Valuation Case Valuation Based on 5 year cash flow projections Facebook can be valued at 41.51 Billion dollars. Based on the analysis and the most likely scenario of projections the company can be fairly valued at 38.2 Billion Dollars but when superimposed on the dynamic pattern of internet businesses a valuation of 41.5 Billion dollars can be assumed a fair value. The company at present has a very strong impact and potential to grow in the near future but at the same time it faces a lot of risks that can put it out of business any time in the future. For Facebook to sustain it must diversify. In the light of new developments and information release regarding Facebook‘s business model, Goldman Sach‘s valuation of the company at 50 Billion dollars is opportunist. The reason for this discrepancy could be a conflict of interest as the company gets a priority while going public. This could also be because of the information limitation. Likelihood NPV (CF) NPV (TV) Facebook Valuation Optimistic Scenario 25% 50.31 10 Pessimistic Scenario 25% 27.68 2 Given the latest improvements and introduction of Facebook email and deals in April, 2011 and also potential talks of evolving it as a search engine with a one stop availability, the company can be valued up to 100 Billion dollars. Realistic Scenario 50% 33.02 5 41.51 *Values in Billion $s The......

Words: 6511 - Pages: 27

Will They Be Friendly?

...16. Will they be Friendly? One question that has plagued the minds of many an educated mind while living on planet earth is the existence of alien life. The earth, which is often referred to as ‘the world’, is the third planet from the Sun and the fifth largest of the eight planets in our Solar System. The earth is only a tiny part of our universe, which is made up of many planets, galaxies, clusters and super clusters. With such an enormous universe, it would be outrageous to even contemplate that there is no extraterrestrial life out there. With this question being so prominent, another question arises and that is ‘if there is other species of life out there, will they be friendly?’ From this question, we can make an assessment on whether we should be advertising our presence by sending messages to stars or just staying quiet. Extraterrestrial life is defined as life that does not originate from earth. ‘Referred to as alien life, or simply aliens these hypothetical forms of life range from simple bacteria-like organisms to beings far more complex than humans’1. Earth is moderately young compared to the rest of the universe, so therefore one can only assume these extra-terrestrials would be far more advanced and complex then ourselves. Although many scientists consider extra-terrestrial life to be plausible, no direct evidence has yet been found. If they do exist, we come back to our will they be friendly question, and we can use certain theories to explore this. A phrase......

Words: 1702 - Pages: 7

Lime 4 Case Study Wild Card Lifeboy

...WILD CARD PERSONAL WASH LIFEBUOY • • LIFEBUOY SUPERFAST HAND WASH CASE STUDY Market Scenario: Consumer Profile: Lifebuoy's Role: • With the rise in incidences of various epidemics globally, there is a structural shift in the Skin Cleansing (SCL) market towards the Health & Hygiene (H&H) products, which is driving category growth. In this market hand wash (HW) is the fastest growing format, growing ahead of bars and body wash, with a potential to grow exponentially. • Lifebuoy is the world's largest H&H brand by volume within the SCL category. However HW is still a small part of the brand currently contributing under 10% of Lifebuoy's overall turnover. • Due to the growth opportunity in the HW market many players are beginning to enter into this segment with tailor made offerings, as such there is a growth in the number of SKUs available in the market. The global HW market has the appetite for more consumer need specific SKUs & variants. • In the HW market some of the major competitors of Lifebuoy are: - Dettol: The biggest player in the H&H HW market, Dettol's message for liquid HW is focused on indicting bar that is used and touched by many people. Dettol is proliferating the market with different variants such as the core germ kill range, naturals range, healthy tough range etc. and are upgrading consumers through premium formats such as HW devices. - Kirei Kirei: A considerable opponent in South East Asian market, Kirei Kirei is focusing on...

Words: 1174 - Pages: 5